2 ms·
I think we're in agreement? I'm saying their measure in this case is no worse than any other, but not that it's a fundamental truth. All the other things — che
by ben_w 2y ago
I think we're in agreement? I'm saying their measure in this case is no worse than any other, but not that it's a fundamental truth.
All the other things — chess, Jeopardy, composing music, painting, maths, languages, passing medical or law degrees — they're also all things which were considered signs of intelligence until AI got good at them.
Goodhart's law keeps tripping us up on the concept of intelligence.
- _heimdall 2y ago> I think we're in agreement? I'm saying their measure in this case is no worse than any other, but not that it's a fundamental truth. Maybe we are? I think I lost the thread a bit here. > chess, Jeopardy, composing music, painting, maths, languages, passing medical or law degrees That's interesting, I would have still chalked skill in those areas as a sign of intelligence and didn't realize most people wouldn't once AI (or ML) could do it. To me an AI/LLM/ML being good at those is at least a sign that they have gotten good at mimicking intelligence if nothing else, and a sign that we really are getting out over our skis risking these tools without knowing how they really work.