3 ms·
I, as a reviewer, made a similar mistake once! The author's initial version seemed to contradict one of their earlier papers but I was missing some context.
by Metacelsus 2y ago
I, as a reviewer, made a similar mistake once! The author's initial version seemed to contradict one of their earlier papers but I was missing some context.
- selfmodruntime 2y agoI also made this mistake! I recommended the author to read an adjacent work, which turned out to be by the very same author. He had just forgot to include it his work.
- adastra22 2y agoI’ve had it happen to me. Paper rejected because it was copying and not citing a prior message to a mailing list… the message from the mailing list was mine, and the paper was me turning it into a proper publication.