5 ms·
America sits on a weird knife edge where there's (a) lots of talk about political violence, which is constitutionally protected and (b) lots of stockpiling of w
by pjc50 2y ago
America sits on a weird knife edge where there's (a) lots of talk about political violence, which is constitutionally protected and (b) lots of stockpiling of weapons, which is constitutionally protected, and (c) lots of routine mass murder incidents, which follow logically from (a) and (b) ..
BUT
.. apart from Jan 6 and a few milita incidents, nobody ever combines these three into politically targeted violence. The mass murders are always either strangers, workplace, or schoolchildren. Politically motivated, but not targeted at any kind of power structure. It's been a long time since the Unabomber. All the elements are in place for a really serious deterioration of civil safety, but so far the glue is holding.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoWeren't there at least two high profile presidential candidate assassination attempts in 2024?
- pjc50 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_Wesley_Routh https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_Wesley_Routh https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Matthew_Crooks https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Matthew_Crooks Indeed. But since they're right wing guys attacking Trump, it seems to have faded from the conversation. Also they failed.
- sadboi31 2y agoYeah they do. Check out the 764 cult + project gladio. Lots of assassinations towards left-leaning folks. Atleast two such cases recorded on forensic architecture of murders of hacktivists going unchecked after quiet obviously being staged by intelligence agencies. One in Germany and one at a BLM event. I wont speak more on it here but I can think of atleast 6 people i've known closely who've just gone completely dark online + in their community after anti-govt organization. I assume they're dead.
- ganoushoreilly 2y agon your (a), (b), and (c) list, you imply that (c) — routine mass murders — connects directly to (a) (talk of political violence) and (b) (stockpiling weapons). However, the examples you give, like Jan. 6 or militia incidents, don’t align with your routine mass murders implication. You could imply unrest for sure and I wholly agree that subsets could even be targeted violence, but that's not unique to either of your examples. The elements will always be in place for disturbed individuals, just look at the number of "Cars running over crowds" stories, such as yesterday in New Orleans. The question and premise for a lot of the battles are, do we take away rights or abilities of those that won't do it, on the off chance that someone could? Clear laws, enforced consistently would help a lot here. I would also posit, though not likely a popular opinion, there are people that cannot be a part of a functioning society and we have to collectively agree on that. We need to bring back functioning mental health facilities for long term care and accept that some people will be placed here and not leave.
- pjc50 2y ago> However, the examples you give, like Jan. 6 or militia incidents, don’t align with your routine mass murders implication That's my point: there's loads of "apolitical" school shootings and much less "political" violence.
- ganoushoreilly 2y agoMy mistake there, I misinterpreted your point of view.
- oceanplexian 2y ago> (c) lots of routine mass murder incidents, Your other points are valid but this one has been so highly politicized that inner city gang violence is classified as mass shooting, which is a completely different social issue that’s being co-opted in with the political violence issue and the mental health crisis. All of those problems are complex and have different root causes, implications and magnitudes, but activists like Everytown want to lump them together to portray a “Gun Problem” to pitch their forced solution, which is making it harder for law-abiding citizens to own guns.
- rat87 2y agoI mean it is a Gun problem. Or rather many Gun problems. If guns were better regulated and we had less of them we would have a safer less violent society. Those other issues would still exist but would lead to less violence. Instead we have activists who claim that any gun laws are unconstitutional going even further then our very activist supreme court.
- devops99 2y agoWe already have a safer less violent society, it's found outside the cities.
- anamax 2y ago> If guns were better regulated We can't stop drug importation. What makes you think that we can stop guns? > and we had less of them we would have a safer less violent society. "less of them"? We can take away all of the deer rifles and not change US violence at all. A collector with 100 guns is not more dangerous than one with 25. The vast majority of US gun violence is committed by people who are already involved in other illegal activities involving other illegal substances. It is absurd to think that they can be disarmed by legal means. It takes about 1% of the "by physical volume" drug smuggling to provide them with a new gun per crime. If anything guns are harder to ban than drugs (because they're easier to make and smuggle), and that was true before 3d printing became a thing.
- 2y ago
- lamontcg 2y agoLuigi?
- pjc50 2y agoSomething of a standout. Will there be copycats?
- specialist 2y agoFYI David Neiwert and others have been documenting the reemergence of politically motivated violence for decades. Also, the Congressional Jan 6 report details extents of (just one coalition of) the paramilitary efforts. Fast forwarding to today, many groups were similarily prepared in the event a Democrat won in 2024. PS- Just one recent example: The plot to kidnap Gov Gretchen Whitmer managed to break thru to corporate media. This wiki has a smattering of the misc terrorist groups involved. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretchen_Whitmer_kidnapping_plot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretchen_Whitmer_kidnapping_pl...