8 ms·
> the more people wonder whether French of Moroccan > extraction really are French or Moroccan, the less > French they are I'm not saying that it's right t
by pyre 14y ago
> the more people wonder whether French of Moroccan
> extraction really are French or Moroccan, the less
> French they are
I'm not saying that it's right to try and exclude them. It's just as stupid as the people in American that want to shutdown immigration to 'dirty foreigners' (forgetting that their ancestors were 'dirty foreigners'). Someone that was originally from Morocco shouldn't be consider 'less French' than someone whose ancestors have been in France for generations, but you can't force this to happen by pretending that people have no past (i.e. country of origin).
Maybe the term 'French-Moroccan' has bad cultural connotations in France that you're trying to get rid of by burying the term, but the term itself, or the facts surrounding it are not inherently bad. If someone is "Chinese-American" or "Japanese-Canadian" or "Mexican-American", the term doesn't make them any less American/Canadian.
> Regarding the riots, that's also not relevant to the
> discussion but because you ask, those riots where the
> results of 40 years of bad policies, social rejection
> and latent racism.
I only bring up the riots with respect to where I got the information that Paris has a large French-Moroccan population.
- GFischer 14y agoThe "country of origin" is very debatable. I consider myself Uruguayan because I was born here, but my great-grandparents were German. However, someone in Tuscany was asked, and he said "my family has only been here for four centuries". Should someone like Zidane be considered French, or "French of Algerian extraction"? By the tuscanian's perspective, there are no Americans, only "American of Irish extraction" and so on, while over here we all consider ourselves Uruguayans. Something you don't understand is that those terms ("Chinese-American") are an US cultural thing. Many of my fellow countrymen (I'm from Uruguay) are extremely shocked when they go to the U.S. ... we've learned about at most 3 races, and you people have 16 !!! One of my teachers likes an anecdote where, when filling a form at San Diego University, he had to ask the clerk what "race" he was - the clerk decided he was "Hispanic", and then there was a sub-category "White Hispanic" or "Black Hispanic". However, he's descendant from Spaniards and probably the exact same racial composition as racists from California that despise "hispanics" (there was a genocide here in Uruguay and we don't have native blood, we're all descendants of spaniards, italians and other european countries, plus some descendants of slaves).
- adodge 14y ago> San Diego University Which? We have several, none of which is called "San Diego University."
- GFischer 14y agoUniversity of San Diego (http://www.sandiego.edu http://www.sandiego.edu) I didn't realize that changing it to San Diego University would change its meaning, sorry (and I didn't realize you had more than one either). I don't know which form he filled, but I found plenty on Google: http://www.sandiego.edu/facts/quick/current/ethnicity.php http://www.sandiego.edu/facts/quick/current/ethnicity.php http://www.sandiego.edu/facts/cds/2011/cdsb.php http://www.sandiego.edu/facts/cds/2011/cdsb.php etcetera, etcetera.
- Scrivner 14y ago> It's just as stupid as the people in American that > want to shutdown immigration to 'dirty foreigners' > (forgetting that their ancestors were 'dirty foreigners'). That is a gross mis-characterization of the American attitude on immigration. Americans don't want to "shut down" immigration. We Americans take pride in our diversity of heritage and our openess to those who want to come to our country and be an American. Our objection is to people who come here illegaly. We object to those who come here and thumb their nose at the law, draw benefits from our government (and therefore depriving legal citizens of those benefits) and overwhelm our system.