2 ms·
Yes, but the issue in the story is the belief of some residents that they have a procedurally enforceable right to prevent water pollution. What could that even
by tptacek 2y ago
Yes, but the issue in the story is the belief of some residents that they have a procedurally enforceable right to prevent water pollution. What could that even mean? We have a pretty standard mental image of "water pollution" (most of us are thinking of a plume of black fluid spreading through a lake) but all sorts of things are polluting, including organic agriculture.
And, like, it's obviously not the case that the counter- right exists, either; you don't have a right to utilize public resources. There's a balance of competing equities, and we have a whole system of government, with a legislature to do fact-finding and establish rules, an executive to do enforcement, and a judiciary to sanity-check the rules and make sure they're enforced consistently. It works... pretty badly, but so does every other system you can imagine.
To claim a "right" in the sense meant by the petitioners in the article is to say that there is a rule that exists above most of that system of governance that gives the judiciary the power to overrule all elected authority in the name of preserving clean water. No? Which water is clean and which isn't is a pretty basic function of government.
- danudey 2y agoI think it is reasonable to assert that the health and survival of both human populations and the natural ecosystem is of critical importance to human society. Therefore, it seems easy to argue that making a water system uninhabitable and causing the collapse of communities or ecosystems should be prevented. Whether the pollution in question is in the form of toxic heavy metals, forever chemicals, etc., or just excessive farm runoff that causes algal blooms and kills marine life (or anything else that consumes the water), that seems like the line to draw. If you're making a water system incapable of sustaining life, then... don't.
- tptacek 2y agoDepends on the circumstances. And, maybe you're right more generally. Maybe the balance of equities will be such that materially compromising the viability of any waterway is proscribed. But a political process works that out, not a natural right.
- mandmandam 2y ago> It works... pretty badly, but so does every other system you can imagine. That's not true. There's been some great work in the area of 'the tragedy of the commons' by Elinor Ostrom, and others, which shows that not only is it possible to protect the commons without top-down regulation, but it's also quite feasible.
- tptacek 2y agoOk, but this doesn't matter to my argument, does it?
- mandmandam 2y agoIf it doesn't matter to your argument, why did you bring it up in the first place? Why would you claim there was no functional alternative, then say it doesn't matter when shown one? The idea that principles for wisely and sustainably managing a commons would have no connection to regulating against water pollution is bizarre to me. I wouldn't know where to start if you don't see how those overlap. > What could that even mean? Read some Ostrom and find out, maybe?
- tptacek 2y agoI did not claim there was no functional alternative.
- mandmandam 2y agoYou claimed that 'every other system you can imagine works pretty badly'. As in, they don't function well. This level of pedantry might serve you well in some areas of life; but here, now, what are you accomplishing? Why not focus on the joyous fact that there not only is there huge room for improvement in this area, but people have in fact already done a huge amount of the groundwork?
- tptacek 2y ago