3 ms·
Absolutely agree with the points of this article. Love this quote: Anyone who thinks they have a unique idea that they want to "own" and milk for money can do
by swombat 18y ago
Absolutely agree with the points of this article.
Love this quote: Anyone who thinks they have a unique idea that they want to "own" and milk for money can do so-but first they have to track down and appropriately compensate all the people who made possible the compilers, algorithms, programming courses, books, hardware, and so forth that put them in a position to have their brainstorm.
The same concept applies to all other forms of "Intellectual Propery" - which, in my opinion, is why Intellectual Property is a contradiction in terms. There is no "property" in the intellectual realms, only a temporary exclusive licence in some cases (like some artistic creations and patentable inventions). To call it "property" is a misnomer with terrible consequences.
The result of this dangerous trend that the RIAA/MPAA and other content publishers have been pushing is that people now feel that because they've created something they have some ownership rights over it, and they feel hurt when someone "steals" it from them.
Actually, one of the greatest gifts of the universe is the fact that ideas are free and intangible, that they can spread with no resource cost, rapidly, until they are supplanted by better ideas. We should welcome this fantastic circumstance and make use of it instead of trying to arbitrarily make it look like physical property.
- davidw 18y ago> We should welcome this fantastic circumstance and make use of it instead of trying to arbitrarily make it look like physical property. Well... yes and no. I absolutely love free software, and if I were really wealthy, would work on nothing else. However, the idea behind creating property where none really exists is this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#Introducing_an_exclusion_mechanism_.28club_goods.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#Introducing_an_excl... With the possibility being that, without any of the mechanisms mentioned, "intellectual property" kinds of things might be underprovisioned. I.e., why sink 5 years of research into a new widget design if you can't even recoup those research costs because someone else just copies your design. That's the theory, anyway. In practice, it's a big, hairy, complex discussion that revolves around various compromises, and in terms of policy, in places like the US, it probably leans too far in favor of IP producers, or at least those with deep pockets.
- netcan 18y agoI would go even further. IP should be done away with legally wherever possible. When in doubt eliminate it. Where it is absolutely necessary, when things just don't get done & no positive equilibrium forms, introduce it. Not as a 'right' any more then a government contract is a right. Just a rule of the game that allows medicine to be developed or technology to improve. I can't possibly see how disappearing music IP would hurt society in aggregate. I dare say music would still be made. The dynamic of the industry would be completely different. Maybe there would be a 10% loss of revenue industry wide. maybe 25% or 50% or even 90%. That still probably leaves a bigger industry then sculpting or comic theatre. Music is very popular. It will not disappear tomorrow. Even in medicine I think it is possible there would be some gains. After all, it's a huge market & will remain so. I'm not sure that public funding for research wouldn't be just as good as private patent-chasing funding it would need to replace. There is a lot of inefficiency in the system now anyway. New antibiotics (probably the most important single class of medicine) are not profitable to develop. A patient take 1 course & then goes home. If you price them high, then doctors will prescribe a different antibiotic. But a new antibiotic will save lives as it will probably work in some end cases where existing ones don't. It's also a bit of insurance against future resistant strains. But the economy for developing antidepressants, cosmetics or some other long term treatment drugs with potentially fewer cheap substitutes is much stronger. This is really pushing it. I don't know to analyse all the economic outcomes. But I know I see no strong moral reason for IP laws other then those that generate the most well being for society. *In reality transitioning would be hugely difficult. I'm not saying throw it out & start from scratch. I'm saying reconsider.