3 ms·
> Very difficult to disrupt American healthcare when health insurance companies determine your rates, This isn’t unique to America. In countries with governmen
by Aurornis 2y ago
> Very difficult to disrupt American healthcare when health insurance companies determine your rates,
This isn’t unique to America. In countries with government healthcare, the government determines your rates. Typically government rates are lower than private insurance rates in the US, too.
For as much as Americans like to complain about insurance companies, we actually get a lot more care and pay higher rates to providers than other countries. There’s a reason doctor pay in the United States is so much higher, among other things.
- llamaimperative 2y agoWhat on earth We get a lot more care, pay higher rates, and have worse outcomes. That last bit is why people are pissed.
- devonkim 2y agoI think we should add that the outcomes are worse at _all_ socioeconomic levels. The rich get screwed over as well in this system as well. It's unfortunate that so many of them have better overall outcomes and/or myopic experiences that many are emotionally invested in being _able_ to pay exorbitant amounts for more personalized care - regardless of the societal consequences - as an interpretation of "freedom." But hey, it's not like the US is a democracy exactly given that public opinion generally doesn't translate into policy changes anymore.
- missedthecue 2y agoI don't think it's settled fact that the US has worse health outcomes. In fact, most data I see points to the opposite. Some people point out very lazy metrics like life expectancy while ignoring that 72% of Americans are overweight or obese according to the CDC. Rearrange healthcare/government insurance models all you want; it can't fix that.
- thrance 2y agoLife expectancy is still lower in the US than in western Europe.
- robertlagrant 2y agoBut engage with the point OP's making. That is despite spending far more on healthcare, so maybe the problem isn't the healthcare? Life expectancy in general in the US could also be due to the amount of gun violence, as well. Nothing to do with the quality of healthcare.
- llamaimperative 2y agoManaging chronic disease burden is a component of healthcare The fact that Americans intuit that it’s not is a worrying sign of just how broken our system is
- robertlagrant 2y ago> Americans intuit that it’s not Any evidence for this?
- llamaimperative 2y agoGP’s comment? It’s predicated on separating “high chronic disease burden” from “poor healthcare system performance.” I don’t think this is a broadly held belief, I think it’s the “eeehhrm actually…” contrarian belief that’s trying to discredit the consensus view that our healthcare system gets very poor results for the money. So it shows up in places like this exact HN thread.
- robertlagrant 2y agoSounds as though you're now not saying that Americans as a group think that. That's good.
- thrance 2y ago
- llamaimperative 2y agoUhhhhh obviously managing chronic disease burden is a core feature of a functional healthcare system. One of the strongest levers we have to improve the “inputs” you’re describing is a better primary care system. America’s has been absolutely gutted over the last 20 years by interactions of various economic and regulatory dynamics including (notably) the anti-competitive vertical integration of pay-viders and pay-vider+PBMs like UnitedHealth Group. It is absolutely not true there aren’t system-level changes we can make in healthcare and insurance to help address this.
- missedthecue 2y agoYes managing chronic disease is good and important but there is no healthcare system that is so good it can outrun an obese population. The healthy population will always do better than infinity spending and care on a sick one.
- llamaimperative 2y agoIt seems like you’re either ignorant of some basic facts about healthcare or are willfully missing the point (true to the username I guess) so I’ll be more explicit: Having access to doctors helps to manage disease. Obesity is a disease. In particular, having access to PCPs helps to manage obesity. Our healthcare system yields poor access to healthcare. In particular, it yields poor access to PCPs. Ergo the obese population is in part an output of and not an external input into the design of our healthcare system. Ergo changes to the healthcare system absolutely can — and in fact should have as a key goal to — yield changes to levels of obesity. > “ Rearrange healthcare/government insurance models all you want; it can't fix that.” This claim is false. The mental model of an obese population being exclusively an input into our healthcare system does not track with what we know about the relationship between healthcare and obesity.