3 ms·
>It's dangerously close to the EA belief that it's actually OK to be a ruthless exec for a tobacco company, because you can do good things with your money that
by gruez 2y ago
>It's dangerously close to the EA belief that it's actually OK to be a ruthless exec for a tobacco company, because you can do good things with your money that you wouldn't be able to do if you quit the job.
You're saying this as if it's a given, but why wouldn't this work?
- Hasu 2y agoFor the same reason people don't think it's OK to rob a bank and donate the money to charity.
- gruez 2y agoThat analogy fails because robbing a bank is straightforwardly illegal and norm-breaking (by the majority of the population), whereas being a tobacco executive isn't.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- layer8 2y agoUnethical behavior not being treated as norm-breaking unless its illegal is part of what’s being criticized here, I think.
- ClumsyPilot 2y agoNot if you ask the younger generation
- worik 2y ago> For the same reason people don't think it's OK to rob a bank and donate the money to charity. I have a problem with violence...
- Avicebron 2y agoBecause it's sociopathic at its core, I don't have time to pull up the HN back and forth where it was debated during the FTX stuff but basically it comes across as, "I am willing to sacrifice others (but not myself) to achieve my goals because I know better."
- gruez 2y ago>but basically it comes across as, "I am willing to sacrifice others (but not myself) to achieve my goals because I know better." Since money is fungible but finite, basically any sort of donation decision involves sacrificing someone. Donating to fund malaria nets when you'd otherwise have funded your local little league team means you're in effect, sacrificing the local little league team. Moreover, by donating their own money, they're by definition "sacrificing myself".
- int_19h 2y agoThis line of thinking (and EA in general) taken to its logical conclusion results in stuff like LW's famous "moral dilemma" about torturing someone for 50 years being justifiable if it prevents sufficiently many people from the discomfort of having a speck in their eye.
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoBecause enabling evil on a large scale to pay for doing good on a small scale doesn't achieve net good.
- jefftk 2y agoIt wouldn't work because being a tobacco exec is just really harmful: https://80000hours.org/2016/01/just-how-bad-is-being-a-ceo-in-big-tobacco/ https://80000hours.org/2016/01/just-how-bad-is-being-a-ceo-i... Anyone who could do that job has many far better ways they could apply their career.