4 ms·
A lot of people miss the fact that this is more art project than practical solution. It’s meant to make a statement, but they have cherry-picked some extremely
by Aurornis 2y ago
A lot of people miss the fact that this is more art project than practical solution. It’s meant to make a statement, but they have cherry-picked some extremely simple drugs to synthesize to make their point.
I have some online friends who met through a forum for their rare condition. The forum they’re in had a splinter group dedicated to getting companies in China to synthesize experimental drugs for them that they couldn’t secure through normal channels, either because they hadn’t been approved yet or because they were expensive and off-label so nobody would even prescribe them.
Even contracting with professional chemical synthesis operations in foreign countries turned out to be more difficult than they imagined. Several companies would take their deposit, then refund part of it after several months because they could never get the synthesis to work properly. They received one batch that tested as being so impure that it was useless.
Projects like this convince people that all drugs are actually really easy to make, when in reality this project has carefully selected the most simple examples to make that misleading point.
- germandiago 2y agoThe story probably has two sides, as you mention. However, I think everyone should be in charge of their own decisions, including taking not approved drugs, without being considered criminals or similar, under their strict own responsibility.
- abduhl 2y agoThis question is pedantic but I’ll ask it anyways: is it actually illegal to take an unapproved drug? Sale of, marketing for, distribution, etc. all might be (are?) illegal but is TAKING an unapproved drug illegal? I can’t believe it is, there’s an entire industry that peddles nootropics and supplements. My understanding has always been that if you can get it (however that is), you can take it without issue (although you obviously might have broken a possession law at some point).
- soulofmischief 2y agoDepending on the drug, it can be illegal for certain professionals to create, procure or otherwise transfer possession or sell it to you. It's not even illegal to consume heroin or crack in normal circumstances, it's only the possession itself which is illegal. Depends on the state, but unscheduled drugs don't typically have possession laws. However, if you use an illegal method to acquire them, and in some case all realistic methods are illegal, you can get in trouble for that.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoIsn't the FDAs rule it becomes controlled once the active ingredient in the supplement is proven to have significant pharmacological effects on health conditions? So you can take it up to and until it becomes clear it has a benefit to you, the you can only take the FDA approved version.
- pjc50 2y agoTaking? Yes. It's the selling and marketing that's the social disaster, see the opiates scandal.
- germandiago 2y agoAs long as that marketing is not misleading and the contract is clear, with all dangers exposed, it should also be legal IMHO. What should not be legal is fooling someone into taking something without knowing its consequences for the potential harm produced. The rest should be ok.
- mathgeek 2y agoIt’s sadly never that simple. You quickly run into “and now we have to regulate it further” at every step because contracts have to be exhaustive in order to be clear, risks cannot be fully known in advance, rational people can disagree about what is misleading, etc.
- germandiago 2y agoThis already happens even with regulations. It is impossible to fix. Also, note thst even with regulations and, more important, INSIDE regulated areas, these things already happen. I think there is a case to discuss what constitutes harm, but pretending that regulated means "harmless and ok" and not regulated "evil and dangerous" is a bad mindset and the one that is dragging us to a false sense of security via hyper regulation. Not always, of course, but in many cases it is just a false sense of it.
- mathgeek 2y ago> This already happens even with regulations. Agreed, that was sadly part of my point. They never end but not having them also doesn’t solve the problem for everyone. Some folks will want more, some won’t, at any balancing point.
- immibis 2y ago
- mistermann 2y ago>when in reality this project has carefully selected the most simple examples to make that misleading point. Can you quote that part?
- snakeyjake 2y ago>Projects like this convince people that all drugs are actually really easy to make, when in reality this project has carefully selected the most simple examples to make that misleading point. For the last thirty or so years ccc has mainly been a place for people to lie or exaggerate on stage in order to promote their security consulting firm or other freelance project. So this is to be expected. If replication in psychology is a crisis, the replication of results from hacker conference talks is an extinction-level apocalypse.
- mistrial9 2y agook but the opposite is also annoying.. where professionals make tiny, safe comments, and their management never discloses at all.. SO you get a nightclub environment like a stage.. let them do it, obviously useful things come out sometimes.
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoContacts for reliable contract synthesis labs in China are kind of a closely held secret. Before the 2017 “general ban” on psychoactive substances in the UK there was a thriving industry where “entrepreneurs” with the contacts for such labs would hire chemists to find them a new candidate analogue/derivative of say, a stimulant or hallucinogen or whatever, knock together a synthesis route, see if it works, and then have it manufactured in bulk for resale to head shops. A small number of people got incredibly rich off this, some got busted when their product got banned and they didn’t dump the stock fast enough, but most made fucking phenomenal amounts of money. The same “trade” carries on in some other European countries to this day, with “new” LSD derivatives cropping up every few months when one is invariably banned. I vaguely recall there was even a few articles about this whole thing back in the day by some journalists, maybe at Vice or something? They had an interview with one of the chemists.
- iancmceachern 2y agoMaybe Hamiltons Pharmacopeia?
- Telemakhos 2y agoPerhaps NPR: https://www.npr.org/2020/11/17/916890880/we-are-shipping-to-the-u-s-china-s-fentanyl-sellers-find-new-routes-to-drug-user https://www.npr.org/2020/11/17/916890880/we-are-shipping-to-... ('We Are Shipping To The U.S.': Inside China's Online Synthetic Drug Networks, 2020) Perhaps NYT: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/22/world/asia/in-china-illegal-drugs-are-sold-online-in-an-unbridled-market.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/22/world/asia/in-china-illeg... (In China, Illegal Drugs Are Sold Online in an Unbridled Market, 2015)
- pantalaimon 2y ago> The same “trade” carries on in some other European countries to this day, with “new” LSD derivatives cropping up every few months when one is invariably banned. AFAIU those were all made by Lizard Labs
- DontchaKnowit 2y agoThose were the good ol days for a druggie teenager. Well "good ol" as in cheap easy access to tons of novel drugs. Which actually made life kind of a living nightmare.
- delecti 2y ago> they have cherry-picked some extremely simple drugs to synthesize to make their point It can't do everything, but those cherry-picked examples are still pretty dramatic. Saving $80k to cure your Hep.C is pretty practical. Getting an abortion while living under increasingly emboldened christofascists is pretty practical. Managing your own transgender HRT is pretty practical. Lets not perfect be the enemy of good, it's a pretty solid start.
- MichaelZuo 2y ago[flagged]
- delecti 2y agoThe comment I replied to was implying that the positives were oversold, but to my read didn't really mention any negatives. What negative consequences are you talking about? Currently your framing makes it seem even better: some (IMO) substantial positive consequences, and no negative ones.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoYou are unable to think of any potential negative consequences of amateur drug synthesis?
- Brian_K_White 2y agoA proof of concept still proves the concept no matter how little it does, as long as it does anything at all. That's neither cherry picking nor misleading.
- tptacek 2y agoWhat's the concept that they're proving, and what do you believe now that you didn't before they presented?
- Brian_K_White 2y agoWhy do you ask? Specifically, this is one stupid question and one irrelevant question. Why do you ask either the stupid question or the irrelevant question? The stupid question is stupid in the same way as: "What color was George Washington's white horse?" The entire presentation is nothing but a continuous stream of synopsys' of proofs of concepts. The answer to the question is nothing other than a verbatim transcript of the video. Irrelevant question: My knowledge of a topic has no bearing on the validity of some presentation on that topic, unless I happen to be challenging or supporting the content of the presentation. It doesn't matter what I believed or knew before or after ingesting the presentation.
- tptacek 2y agoBecause if the idea they're proving is that basic chemistry does what textbooks say basic chemistry should do I'm not sure I understand the impact of the "POC" here. That's all; I'm not baiting, I'm genuinely wondering what I'm missing.
- Brian_K_White 2y agoWell, again, the text of the video. No more but no less either. It's not merely showing that already known basic chemistry works as we already knew it worked. It's almost like but again not merely showing that you can make your own cottage cheese at home instead of buying it as a commercially made product. Countless medecines, and their delivery mechanisms, exist that could be produced in a more diy way, but most people don't know it, because of basically PR driven by the people who make money from medications and health care in general. That PR encompassing both ordinary direct messaging to the population and doctors, and lobbying for regulation and direct influence over regulating bodies and standards bodies by being members themselves, etc. The true issues of quality control and safety etc have been grossly over-used to justify removing options and control from end users. I did not know that you could make your own epi pen. That is the kind of thing that everyone should know. I don't mean that everyone should know how to do it, I mean everyone should know it's possible and always there as an option the same way everyone knows you could make your own cheese. That is one example that answers both questions. It proved the concept that such a thing is possible, and I myself also happened not to know it before watching the video. I don't think it is invalid or not a proof of concept even if there already exists people with the right knowledge such that they consider the contents of an epi pen "basic chemistry". It is still a revelating proof of concept that one can produce one's own epi-pen, and that the only thing preventing countless people from being able to take advantage of such a huge practicality, is a combination of various forms of artificial barriers that should all be insubstantial, but in the end they do end up acheiving the result that the epi-pen producer wants. No one makes their own epi-pens nor produces them in a cheap generic form (in the US). That particular example isn't even new. When I google "make your own epi-pen" I see it comes from 2016. That does not mean it's not a proof of concept, it just demonstrates how those insubstantial barriers never the less worked. Not just because I personally did not know about this public thing that was there to be googled since 2016, but because in fact all the people who pay US health care rate for epi-pens unwillingly. I think it doesn't matter if a concept is new or already known to some. A video demonstrating that it's possible to start a fire without a match is still a proof of concept even if some humans have known how to do that for thousands of years.