3 ms·
> It appears that only one person (Professor Nicely) noticed the bug in actual use. I recall a study done years ago where students were supplied calculators fo
by WalterBright 2y ago
> It appears that only one person (Professor Nicely) noticed the bug in actual use.
I recall a study done years ago where students were supplied calculators for their math class. The calculators had been doctored to produce incorrect results. The researchers wanted to know how wrong the calculators had to be before the students noticed something was amiss.
It was a factor of 2.
Noticing the error, and being affected by the error, are two entirely different things.
I.e. how many people check to see if the computer's output is correct? I'd say very, very, very few. Not me, either, except in one case - when I was doing engineering computations at Boeing, I'd run the equations backwards to verify the outputs matched the inputs.
- wat10000 2y agoI used to tutor physics in college. My students would show a problem they worked and ask for feedback, and I’d tell them that they definitely went wrong somewhere since they calculated that the rollercoaster was 23,000 miles tall. Which is to say, it will depend a lot on the context and the understanding of the person doing the calculation.
- WalterBright 2y agoIt is institute policy at Caltech (at least when I attended) that obviously wrong answers would get you zero credit, even if the result came from a minor error. However, if you concluded after solving the problem that the answer was absurd, but you didn't know where the calculation went wrong, you'd get partial credit.
- kllrnohj 2y ago> Noticing the error, and being affected by the error, are two entirely different things. Only somewhat true. Take any consumer usage here for example. If you're playing a game and it hits this incorrect output but you don't notice anything as a result, were you actually affected? How much usage of FDIV on a Pentium was for numerically significant output instead of just multimedia?
- WalterBright 2y agoIf your game has some artifacts in the display, nobody cares. But if you're doing financial work, scientific work, or engineering work, the results matter. An awful lot of people used Excel. BTW, telling a customer that a bug doesn't matter doesn't work out very well.
- garaetjjte 2y agoUnless your multiplayer game desyncs due to different division result on other computer.