3 ms·

It's mentioned three times in the article, including: "We want this to be a community of open source game developers, communicating with each other and talking

by jpgg 14y ago

It's mentioned three times in the article, including: "We want this to be a community of open source game developers, communicating with each other and talking about current efforts and future efforts in a powerfully creative environment."

Danieru 14y ago
And the most damning: >After all, isn’t that what open source is all about – the idea that collaboration and teamwork achieve amazing things?
- slurgfest 14y ago
  Damning in the sense that a game company wishes to sell games commercially? God forbid that they do such a thing! Yes, I suppose it is better for Linux if nobody attempts to sell commercial software which could work with Linux, ever.
  - Ralith 14y ago
    He means that a closed source platform isn't exactly conventional open source collaboration. Sure, it might be a boon anyway, but that doesn't make the rhetoric accurate.
  - lsh 14y ago
    Don't be melodramatic. Damning in the sense that open source, the idea, is not what they are interested in but are riding it's coattails in order to encourage developers who are interested. This thread is a little overblown and it's too early to point fingers and thump chests - lets see what they put on offer first.
    - weego 14y ago
      Unfortunately it's never too early for the Linux union to go big on the blame and drama. Sometimes the product doesn't even have to be out before someone starts the bile because they can't see the source.
    - slurgfest 14y ago
      It is ridiculous to begin talking about things as "damning" when a company is doing nothing but dedicating resources to the cultivation of Linux as a platform for video game development and (yes) the sale and consumption of commercial games. The word "damning" should not even arise. Don't lecture me about thumping chests and waiting to see what they put on offer, I am responding to inflamed language being applied to a company for no reason other than that they sell software.
      - Ralith 14y ago
        Relax, it was just bad word choice.
        Danieru 14y ago
        I meant damning in the 'Valve has been accused of miss-using the term open source' and here is perfect evidence, sense. I love what Valve is doing and I want to encourage them. Still, their usage is just a bit, 'missing the point'.

by jpgg 14y ago

Danieru 14y ago

And the most damning: >After all, isn’t that what open source is all about – the idea that collaboration and teamwork achieve amazing things?

slurgfest 14y ago
Damning in the sense that a game company wishes to sell games commercially? God forbid that they do such a thing! Yes, I suppose it is better for Linux if nobody attempts to sell commercial software which could work with Linux, ever.
- Ralith 14y ago
  He means that a closed source platform isn't exactly conventional open source collaboration. Sure, it might be a boon anyway, but that doesn't make the rhetoric accurate.
- lsh 14y ago
  Don't be melodramatic. Damning in the sense that open source, the idea, is not what they are interested in but are riding it's coattails in order to encourage developers who are interested. This thread is a little overblown and it's too early to point fingers and thump chests - lets see what they put on offer first.
  - weego 14y ago
    Unfortunately it's never too early for the Linux union to go big on the blame and drama. Sometimes the product doesn't even have to be out before someone starts the bile because they can't see the source.
  - slurgfest 14y ago
    It is ridiculous to begin talking about things as "damning" when a company is doing nothing but dedicating resources to the cultivation of Linux as a platform for video game development and (yes) the sale and consumption of commercial games. The word "damning" should not even arise. Don't lecture me about thumping chests and waiting to see what they put on offer, I am responding to inflamed language being applied to a company for no reason other than that they sell software.
    - Ralith 14y ago
      Relax, it was just bad word choice.
      - Danieru 14y ago
        I meant damning in the 'Valve has been accused of miss-using the term open source' and here is perfect evidence, sense. I love what Valve is doing and I want to encourage them. Still, their usage is just a bit, 'missing the point'.