3 ms·
> And if Dark Google has not yet figured out how to scam AI... it is only a matter of time. There is one thing the AI companies have going for them that Google
by AnthonyMouse 2y ago
> And if Dark Google has not yet figured out how to scam AI... it is only a matter of time.
There is one thing the AI companies have going for them that Google doesn't: They don't have 90% market share.
That's a huge problem that only Google has, because if your black hat SEO stops working against Google, you dedicate all your efforts to fixing it until it does, and then Google has to win against the combined efforts of everyone in the world.
Now suppose there were a dozen search engines that all had around equal market share. You find something that works against the first one but that causes you to get dropped to page 10 by two of the other ones. You finally find something that works against three quarters of them... for a week... after which it still works against a third of them but doing that causes the other two thirds to drop you again. To have any chance with those now you have to stop doing that, but if you do you fall off the front page for the third it was still working against. Also, by the end of the month that third will be a quarter.
You could target only one specific search engine, but then you're doing the same amount of work for only 8% of the advantage, meanwhile that search engine can concentrate their efforts on thwarting the similarly smaller percentage of black hat SEOs who chose to target them instead of one of the competing search engines.
It's much harder to hit a dozen moving targets at once than just one.
- squiggleblaz 2y agoIf beating SEO was something a company with a different algorithm could do, then it would have happened by now. Google remains the default search engine because the alternatives are perhaps even more susceptible to SEO than Google, so there just isn't the motivation to use them. Why do I have to go to the second or third page to find an answer with a naive search on DDG?
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> If beating SEO was something a company with a different algorithm could do, then it would have happened by now. The reductio of this argument is that nothing can ever change or improve because if it was possible someone would have done it already. More to the point, people who have used Kagi seem to speak favorably of it. A search engine you have to pay for is never going to be the mass market option, but it can have enough users to be self-sustaining and remain one of the options, and it proves it can be done.