5 ms·
For me, this is a human rights issue. Article 13 of https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universa
by zahlman 2y ago
For me, this is a human rights issue. Article 13 of https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma... is not contingent upon ownership of a smartphone.
- noodlesUK 2y agoI do agree that conceptually the government shouldn’t force you to buy things from private companies to exercise your rights. However, you already have to buy a passport (often for a lot of money) in most countries, so pragmatically, I don’t know that it’s a hugely different thing to ask. However, there’s a big difference for children, the elderly, and people with disabilities. Immigration tends to stretch human rights though. It costs >10k gbp in visa fees for a British citizen to return to the UK with a non-UK spouse from arrival to settlement. You also need to be earning a fair bit of money, and not have the British partner as a stay at home spouse. I would say that frustrates article 8 ECHR, but the government disagrees. There are countless examples of similar issues re international travel and immigration. Smartphone ownership is simply one of many.
- rcbdev 2y agoIssuing a passport by the Austrian State Printing House costs 60€. Show me a phone with decent battery life that has comparable costs.
- shakna 2y agoIf you are convicted of hacking in Australia, you may be subject to a lifetime order that prevents you from owning a smartphone. However, once your parole is done, you do have freedom of travel. Ownership of a device simply is not a guarantee you can rest on - even before you get to those who may not be able to use them.
- noodlesUK 2y agoI completely agree. There are a variety of reasons why a person might be digitally excluded. Governments need to make sure that people can access the services that they’re entitled to through a wide variety of channels, including physically visiting an office if necessary. Though I will say, at a practical level, you will find that it’s increasingly difficult for people with criminal records to travel internationally (due to entry requirements).
- sudoshred 2y agoEntitled is a strong word, eligible is maybe more precise.
- jolmg 2y ago"They're entitled to" or "Have a right to" seem more precise than "eligible". At least in my country, I think everyone (citizens) has the right to a passport. It's not something you need to be chosen for as "eligible" would imply.
- sudoshred 2y agoMy reasoning is that eligibility is a prerequisite for entitlement. I believe eligible is defined as meeting some criteria for, not necessarily being chosen though that could be a criteria. I agree they have a right to, however entitlement implies to me that the person has invested some time and resources in asserting their right. Whereas eligible means only that the right to something exists, if it were to be asserted.
- jolmg 2y agoThe way I see it "entitle" = "in title". People in their title as citizens have a right (often from birth and unalienable) to certain things such as passports. "Eligible" means you're able to be elected, but you must still be elected. Different from a passport, you may be eligible to a visa, and at some point an officer is likely going to interview you and decide whether to give you one. People are entitled to a passport but only eligible to a visa. You can assert what you're entitled to, but not what you're eligible to. > entitlement implies to me that the person has invested some time and resources in asserting their right That's only when your title was earned, which not all are; some are born into them. > I believe eligible is defined as meeting some criteria for, not necessarily being chosen though that could be a criteria. The confusion may have started when decisions became more automated into "criteria" to be checked for by bureaucrats that no longer have the deciding power they once had (and later further automated by software), but "chosen" is in the latin root of the word. For example, "chosen" in Spanish is "elegido", "choosable" would be "elegible". "Eligible" = "electable" = "choosable". They're all basically synonyms.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zahlman 2y ago>However, you already have to buy a passport (often for a lot of money) in most countries From the government, paying what is more an administration fee than the actual cost of the good, yes. This is about principles, not economics.
- c-cube 2y agoA paper passport can be valid for 10 years (maybe more, I'm not sure). It can be stashed in a safe. It can be left alone for several years and be picked up just before leaving for the airport. A smartphone will not satisfy any of these properties.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zamadatix 2y agoThe UDHR is more a list of (short descriptions of) ideals than exact wording of the law to get there or when other things take priority. The 2 sentences making up that article don't really live up to that level of useful detail.
- rkagerer 2y agoEspecially when these days it's near impossible to truly own your own smartphone.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- steelframe 2y agoI've simply been buying Pixel phones and using the GrapheneOS web installation tool. It holds your hand through unlocking the bootloader and flashing the new image on, and it always works without a hitch. Super-easy and reliable. I suppose you still don't "own" the radio firmware, but at least you can have a perfectly functional Google-free Android phone that way. I suppose the real trouble comes from needing to install software from the Google Play store in order to travel. If you feel you need to do that you can create a new Google account just for that installation of the Google Play from the phone itself and then never give it any of your personal information such as a payment method. GrapheneOS claims to do a pretty good job of sandboxing Google Play components. Regardless I agree with others here who think it should always be possible to travel without any electronics on your person.
- Freak_NL 2y agoI use GrapheneOS, and wouldn't have it any other way, but its prolonged existence depends on Google not making any asshole moves in their next Pixels, and on the (highly appreciated) efforts of a few dedicated individuals. And like Linux on the desktop: it offers a better experience for everyone who either has the knowledge to step off the beaten path, or has someone who supports them. But that is just a few percent of people. The rest gets what market forces dictate.
- rkagerer 2y agoChris Woope nicely summarizes the main anti-user features I'd like to surgically remove from GrapheneOS: https://github.com/chriswoope/resign-android-image?tab=readme-ov-file#adb-root https://github.com/chriswoope/resign-android-image?tab=readm... I just wish there were a supported and easier way of achieving this. Would love any suggestions.
- highcountess 2y ago[flagged]