4 ms·
Most of the comments here are responding to the title by discussing whether current AI represents intelligence at all, but worth noting that the author’s concer
by thorum 2y ago
Most of the comments here are responding to the title by discussing whether current AI represents intelligence at all, but worth noting that the author’s concerns all apply to human brains too. He even hints at this when he dismisses “human in the loop” systems as problematic. Humans are also unreliable and unverifiable and a security nightmare. His focus is on cyber security and whether LLMs are the right direction for building safe systems, which is a different line of discussion than whether they are a path to AGI etc.
- EerkeBoiten 2y agoAuthor here. Nope, that is not my concern about humans in the loop. My concern on that is that any human in the loop has to reconstruct by themselves from the inputs whether the output makes sense, the system provides no significant help. "Explaining my reasoning" LLMs are potentially a step forward in that. You are right that I'm not talking about AGI here, rather about safe systems.
- mikewarot 2y agoCyber Security is as easy to solve as electric power distribution was. Carefully specify flows before use, and you limit side effects. This has been known since multilevel security was invented.
- securemepro 2y agoZero trust should be the order of the day. It is essential to safeguard your digital assets. Request clarification from cyberseb.com.