3 ms·
Eek, Valley vs Alley flamewar approaching! The downside here is that the article doesn't really do a great job of explaining the "move to New York" comment. I
by untog 14y ago
Eek, Valley vs Alley flamewar approaching!
The downside here is that the article doesn't really do a great job of explaining the "move to New York" comment. I live in NYC and I agree that the tech scene is far less of a bubble than the Valley, simply because we are surrounded by so many different industries. Everyone in the Valley is in tech, but I have friends here in NYC in fashion, banking, media... you name it. I don't think it's a coincidence that a lot of NYC startups touch on these industries.
But when you say:
They talk about real problems. Like loneliness or stress or sickness or unemployment or high prices or lack of education.
It sounds bad. Like, "typical arrogant New Yorker" bad. There is a valid point being made here, but I fear that it's going to get lost.
- BadassFractal 14y agoI just don't think you can ever have a rational New York vs SV debate without folks getting really passionate about their life choices.
- untog 14y agoI suspect you are correct. Different people have different priorities, and this is A Good Thing.
- abbasmehdi 14y ago"Like loneliness or stress or sickness or unemployment or high prices or lack of education." I actually experienced this first hand recently while on a long trip spanning multiple cities in the US and Canada. People seemed to have a very different set of problems/concerns on top of their minds outside of SV. It was weird at first, but then it became very refreshing. I am not a New Yorker and will dare make the same comment as Michael Waxman (disclosure: Michael is a friend) - step outside SV and people's problems switch away from Socialcam vs Viddy to I can't make my mortgage, I'm getting sick, our kids won't move out etc.
- chipotle_coyote 14y agoBecause people in Santa Clara County don't have issues relating to housing and health care? I've seen this argued before by various people from Alex Payne to Buzz Andersen and I'm starting to feel like it may be a good idea to add an asterisk to this assertion: this is a function of the people in SV that you happen to be talking to. It's true that many of the startups in Silicon Valley and San Francisco are focused on "social media" and this leads to an awful lot of circle jerking that may be sharply lessened in other places, but it's not too difficult to find all sorts of startups out here that are focused on less abstract problems than how open the Twitter API is. (Also, I think that just as people out here can miss the circle-jerkiness of the Silicon Valley scene, people in other cities sometimes tend to miss their own brands of it.)
- abbasmehdi 14y agoI think you have a good point - cities might be statistically similar but getting out to another city might help in stepping out of your usual circle, which is not to say you cannot do the same while staying in your hometown. Side note: This reminds me of a conversation I had with Wesley Zhao, a co-founder of Family Leaf, who said he finds it refreshing to hang out with normals while working on Family Leaf in Palo Alto. It's great advice for a tech founders to actively seek this out IMO.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ryguytilidie 14y agoI think its funny that New Yorkers always tell me how they're surrounded by a variety of industries whereas all us San Franciscans know is tech. My office in SF is in the Financial district, with probably 50 banks within a 10 block radius. 3 blocks over is Union Square, which has a Niemann Marcus, Macys, Nordstrom's, Tiffany's, Louis Vuitton, (essentially you name the high fashion company, its there), 2 blocks the other way is Chinatown, one of the biggest concentrations of Chinese culture. To imply that those of us out here are living in a bubble where all we can experience is tech makes me think one just needed to grasp at straws for why NY is better...
- untog 14y agoI think the distinction here is SF != SV.
- SeoxyS 14y agoI'm with you here, I think San Francisco is an awesome and diverse city. But I think that people who talk about Silicon Valley being insular are talking about the actual valley: Sunnyvale to Menlo Park. And they have a point; if you're in the valley, you're definitely missing out on the many advantages of being in a real city surrounded by real people (whether it's NY or SF).