8 ms·
J G A Pocock's "Machiavellian Moment"
- ashoeafoot 2y ago[flagged]
- jrflowers 2y agoWhy are you writing like Dennis from It’s Always Sunny? You could have just posted “I am very smart :-D”
- ashoeafoot 2y agoThe disability does not dissappear by knowing about it. Im a guy in a mental wheel chair, same as you.
- delichon 2y agoThermodynamics. Politics is about the struggle to control the flow of energy between organisms. History is about creating narratives of that struggle, in order to learn to tap the flow or to direct it. To a first approximation, a history that's disinterested in politics is like a football game commentary that's disinterested in the score.
- devindotcom 2y agoI realize this is largely a lost battle but strictly speaking "disinterested" means no interest in the sense of "conflict of interest." A disinterested party has no "interest" in one outcome over another and can therefore be trusted to be impartial in the matter. "Uninterested" means what you wrote, they are not interested in something in the more everyday sense of the word. Not everyone thinks it matters but the two words do have distinct meanings, and in some situations (like in conversations about values, politics, etc) it is actually worthwhile to be precise so that one does not inadvertently mislead the reader.
- delichon 2y agoMerriam Webster agrees with you for word sense 1a, but with me for word sense 1b. So you win and I agree that uninterested is a better choice here.
- LordDragonfang 2y agoI mean, beyond even the general truism that history is written by the "victors" - not just in war, but in soft political power as well - the choice of which parts of history you decide are important enough to present and which you omit is itself inherently a political decision.
- ajuc 2y agoIt's not written by victors. Look at Jewish history. Or Polish. Or basically any small European country. If anything - losing and surviving makes you more likely to write what you went through than just winning. And people who believe their pasts were better than futures tend to look into history more. History is mostly written by survivors, and losing is a powerful motivation for self-reflection. You can even see it in US with the different attitude people have towards civil war history. How many hardcore civil war history enthusiasts do you know that are mostly interested in Union?
- LordDragonfang 2y agoYou're ignoring that I specifically included soft power. Garnering sympathy as an underdog is a historically effective form of soft power. To your point: not to sound like an antisemitic conspiracy theorist, but it's pretty clear that while the Jewish people have been the victims of many tragedies, they also have managed to accumulate a great deal of political soft power as well, even while being a disadvantaged minority. That's why certain types are so obsessed over the so-called "culture war". While some people just want a right to live and love who they want, the currently dominant cultural factions see that as a threat to their ability to, among other things, control the narrative of history for their own gain.
- ajuc 2y agoI am Polish. I know this from experience. The parts of history we focus on are the parts where we lost. When a society loses political power - it focuses on history and culture to survive (as opposed to "integrating"). Which influences the culture in a self-reinforcing way. Very easy to end up with martyrdom complex. That's what Jews have been doing for 2000 years and their history is one of the best studied out there. When a society wins political power - it looks into the future. A few eggheads will write the history but nobody'll read it. Soft power is secondary - it comes FROM losing and focusing on history. Victors go split the loot, losers go write how they were the "moral winners".
- kazinator 2y agoNo, history is not always political. Political history is political, but there are other kinds of histories. Almost every sphere of human activity has history attached to it. Anything you do, people did before and there is a chain of influences and knowledge. We have to concede that the major developments in any of those histories do intersect with politics. For instance, if we trace the history of almost anything across the years 1940 to 1950, we almost certainly cannot ignore the both the disruptive and reinforcing effect of World War II. A lot of progress in STEM was accelerated by the war. But there isn't going to be a detailed political discussion there if our historic focus is something in STEM and not politics. The political details are tangential to that kind of history. That's not to deny that there isn't an interesting point of view in exploring the connections among different threads of history. James Burke's fantastic Connections series comes to mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(British_TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(British_TV_series... Some people are keenly interested in the history of their profession or hobbies. E.g. musicians interested in the history of music, or the development of their favorite instrument and such. Hackers, software devs and computer scientists interested in the history of computing and retrocomputing. Etc. Usually they are not into the political connection unless they are also interested in politics.
- tossandthrow 2y agoAttribution in science is one of these areas where people are led to believe that is apolitical. But when you dive into it, it is almost cringy. An obvious example is the story about Alan Turing that mostly leaves out the foundational work carried out in Poznan.
- labster 2y agoOr how women’s contribution to sciences were continually overlooked and sometimes purposefully hidden, going along with the social/political status of women. History is stories we tell ourselves about the world, stories backed by the evidence not yet lost to entropy. But which stories we choose to tell and which to forget — and what records to preserve — are always influenced by politics.
- paxys 2y agoThe definition of both history and politics is vague and broad enough that there's guaranteed to be a complete overlap between the two. Anything that ever happened is history. The reason why things happened a certain way (at least in the form it was written down) is politics.
- gsf_emergency 2y ago>Pocock’s claim is that history writing is, to some extent, political in itself. Future historiographers might note a similar relationship between the papers of computer scientists and the economy.. In particular: >history is the most powerful element in the construction and destruction of self-knowledge of political societies I wish the reviewer had attended to the novel thing that Pocock had pointed out about the age-old tension between collectivism and humanism, though: The time scale factor. (Think tech debt) The key phrase 'Machiavellian Moment' is only mentioned in passing as >the difficulty he faced in reconciling an ideal of citizenship with the uncertain and temporal character of republics.
- JasserInicide 2y agoI only read a chunk of the article but this stuck out: In sum, Pocock was paradoxically under attack for being too liberal, but also for not being liberal enough. Said differently, Pocock was criticised for being too American and for not being American enough – all the more intriguing for a New Zealander. If you have both sides criticizing you, chances are you got pretty close to a truth. Reminds me of Dave Chappelle, someone that both left and right culture warriors turned on in recent years.
- 75hfe02 2y agoThis is a lazy heuristic. It abdicates actually engaging with the substance of what someone is saying and weighing it against your own judgement in favor of seeing how much of a spectacle they've managed to create. No, creating more of a spectacle does not indicate that someone is closer to the truth.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoThe other option is that if both sides are critisizing you, you are completely nuts. Saying the moon is made of green cheese isn't going to get support from the progressives or reactionaries.
- basfo 2y agoWith that argument, fascist regimes would be pretty close to the truth, since they were criticized by both liberal democracies and communist countries. Also, you’re assuming there are always only two positions on a given topic. I know it might look that way on Twitter—most people today seem weaponized to pick one side or the other—but real social studies are far more nuanced than that. The fact that everyone criticizes you only means that whatever you say doesn’t align with their narrative, not that you’re close to the truth.
- Loughla 2y agoI find it interesting that we're in a post truth society now, and it may not mean what I think it means. While considering your last paragraph I realized that post truth doesn't necessarily mean absence of fact. It's simply people trying to write history while living it instead of waiting for it to actually be history or relying on experts to maintain an historical account. Facts don't matter. What gets remembered is all that matters, really. Fascinating.
- Animats 2y agoThis is a book review of The_Machiavellian_Moment.[1] I haven't read it. Sounds interesting. The reviewer's comments are more about modern interpretations of the American revolution and constitutional convention than the events themselves. The US constitution was the result of an attempt to build something that wouldn't easily break. That's clear from the debates at the convention, and the Federalist Papers, all of which survive and are still widely read. The US constitution was Version 2. Version 1 was the Articles of Confederation, which created a weak central government subordinate to the states. That government was closer to the United Nations or the European Union than a national government. It wasn't strong enough. The framers knew they needed a strong central government. They expected the British to come back and try to re-conquer the United States, which happened in the war of 1812. The obvious solution was a monarchy. Hamilton wanted that. (He wanted to be King.) Nobody else did. They'd fought a war to get out from under a king. The other worry was descent into anarchy and mob rule. Which is what happened in the French revolution. Followed by years of civil wars, then Napoleon. So the framers wanted something between those extremes. They had the advantage that most of the colonies already had elected representatives and governors, and that seemed to be working. So there was a model to copy. Much stability was built-in, such as 6-year terms for senators. Impeachment was made possible but hard. The President can't dissolve Congress and call a new election, as in a parliamentary system. Congress controls spending. It's not perfect, and it's being stressed at the moment, but it's still holding together. Most of the rest was trying to work out the spheres of control of the federal and state governments. The original plan was that the Federal government is in charge of war, foreign policy, and interstate commerce, and the states do everything else. That's still pretty much the case. There's far more interstate commerce, but most government is still state level and below. That's rare, worldwide. There were many arguments and compromises. But the Framers, on the whole, did a good job. It's worth reading the Federalist papers as a design exercise. There are strange interpretations of what the framers did. There are people who claim they were divinely inspired. But no; the debates show lots of arguments and compromise. They were very afraid of failing. "We must all hang together, or we will all hang separately". Which would have happened had Britain won the war of 1812, which was a close thing. The British reached the Capitol and burned it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Machiavellian_Moment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Machiavellian_Moment
- 2y ago
- dang 2y agoAll: if you're going to comment, please engage with the specifics of the article (there are a lot of them) and not just its baity title. (We've changed that above now.) (Generic ideological tangents are boring and therefore off topic here - see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]