3 ms·
I don't see how getting Dan Bull to not express his views is not censorship. Perhaps not governmental (in the USA, in other countries, we have "Crown Copyright
by bediger4000 14y ago
I don't see how getting Dan Bull to not express his views is not censorship. Perhaps not governmental (in the USA, in other countries, we have "Crown Copyright").
As far as my belief goes, yes, you (and whoever would like to) should collect all of my Hacker News comments, and republish them as widely as possible. I personally don't believe in the legitimacy of the concept of "intellectual property". Independent invention pretty much negates "intellectual property" in my viewpoint, but I also believe that the harm of keeping other people from doing things outweighs any benefits society (or individuals) get from squelching some arbitrary expression.
So, collect and publish away! I still have my ideas, and when you distribute them so will many, many others! We all win!
- mcguire 14y agoI suspect the actual question should be, "I mean, suppose I were to collect all of your Hacker News comments and publish them as "The Collected Works of imgabe" without your permission and without compensating you. Do you believe that should be protected as free speech?"
- bediger4000 14y agoA flat "yes". I still stand by my rationale. imgabe didn't "steal" my ideas, I still have them. So do more people, now that the ideas got spread around. imgabe is more than welcome to go to the work of collecting, collating and publishing anything attributed to "bediger4000" on hacker news. The price to society is just too high otherwise. Also, maybe imgabe really did have those ideas, maybe I'm already just copying. But also, what's the harm? imgabe will be discovered as a fraud, when he/she/it/them can't produce any more instantly viral, utterly quotable 3-sentence analyses of difficult situations. Or when someone tries to look up a phrase in Google. imgabe is not bediger4000. I have a natural monopoly on the witticisms of bediger4000.
- mcguire 14y agoAll good points. Especially, "The price to society is just too high otherwise."
- danielweber 14y agoDan Bull has built a business that depends on partnering with a business entity that is extremely nervous about DMCA violations. That doesn't give him extra protections against DMCA violations. When Don Imus was suspended by his employer for talking about nappy-headed hos on national radio, it wasn't a violation of Imus's free speech rights. YouTube channels seem designed more for people who want to make money from pageviews than for people who want to make righteous stands for free speech. It seems up until very recently he liked that arrangement, but now he finds out that there's no free lunch.
- imgabe 14y agoIt's not preventing him from expressing his views. It's preventing him from using specific sequences of words, images, and/or music that have been used by other people before. He can still express the thoughts behind those in his own words if he wishes to do so. If I want, I can write my own novel about cloning dinosaurs. I cannot simply reprint Jurassic Park without permission.