5 ms·
We object to the Newspaper Licensing Agency's terms
- dbcoops 14y agoIt seems like the content provider has little downside to doing this. News aggregator sends traffic to their page + news site seeks 'licensing' fees for that traffic = profit. I suppose there is the potential for the newspaper to lose money in legal fees as well as look like a jerk to people on the internet, but hey, gotta fight the inevitable demise of print media somehow.
- Jacqued 14y agoSometimes I just wish they would go out of business already. I think google should stop infringing their copyright too. You know, indexing Their Stuff and making links to it. That could do the trick. I wonder what they'd say then. We see first hand what happens when disrupting incumbents who happen to also control politicians and have some good friends in the legal system. Hopefully the current people movement against copyright mafia will see further victories...
- socksy 14y agoWhat does it mean to go out of business? Don't most newspapers make a loss? [1] (Excluding The Sun, obviously.) I don't think the motivation for funding them is profit, but influence, and so they'll continue to be produced for quite a while. Regarding Google, didn't Murdoch complain about just that? [2] [1] Well, at least The Times and The Guardian. http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jul/20/times-paywall-readership http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jul/20/times-paywall-re... mentions a daily loss of £240,000 for The Times, and http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jun/10/guardian-media-group-results http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jun/10/guardian-media-g... suggests similar (if not as great) losses by The Guardian. http://moreintelligentlife.com/content/ideas/tim-de-lisle/can-guardian-survive http://moreintelligentlife.com/content/ideas/tim-de-lisle/ca... suggests a calculation of £100,000 a day. However, The Telegraph appears to make a profit, as suggested here because of merging their digital and print media: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/mar/18/telegraph-group-profits-increase http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2011/mar/18/telegraph-group-... — though I get the feeling that it would still be funded somewhat past the point of profitability too… [2] http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/apr/07/rupert-murdoch-google-paywalls-ipad http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/apr/07/rupert-murdoch-g...
- Jacqued 14y agoGood point. However, I think even Mr Murdoch's personal wealth could not sustain the losses of digital news outlets should Google comply and stop indexing them. By any means, they just have to put a little piece of text in their robots file to do just that - so this is yet more talk in favor of strong copyrights, and no action to renew anything.
- socksy 14y agohttp://www.thetimes.co.uk/robots.txt http://www.thetimes.co.uk/robots.txt would suggest that they are already doing that for their paywalled sites, wouldn't it?
- drivingmenuts 14y ago> It seems like the content provider has little downside to doing this. Seems obvious, but not to everyone. Some of those companies are trying everything they can to claw a buck (or in this case, a pound) wherever they can, no matter who it hurts. The sensible thing for cutbot to do is just cut them off (no pun intended).
- gwillen 14y agoFirst comment: "Interesting. These would be the same newspapers that once quoted my blog, without warning. This caused a traffic spike, and a hit to my hosting bill. I look forward to my forthcoming claim against The Times." Because of course, it's not that the newspapers think any view of a webpage or usage of a headline is infringing, oh no. They just want this rule to apply to Their Stuff, which is Worth Protecting. Not to Your Stuff.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 14y agoMy favorite such case was when the Belgian newspapers sued Google for linking to their sites, and then when Google stopped doing it because they actually won that lawsuit, they came back begging to Google to include them again, once their traffic dropped significantly. http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110718/16394915157/belgian-newspapers-give-permission-to-google-to-return-them-to-search-results.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110718/16394915157/belgia...
- freehunter 14y agoIt really disappoints me that Google would relist those sites. I would have demanded the money spent in court fees as payment for relisting, and if they didn't want to pay it... Google's under no obligation to list any site.
- gte910h 14y agoWhile it's fun to be vindictive, google surely made money by listing ads for those sites, and was probably happy to put them back and get the ad revenue again.
- vibrunazo 14y agoThere was also this case reported by TorrentFreak (sorry couldn't find the link). Where this guy from a record label was making a huge deal about one of the bands he managed was being pirated to death. The band only had sold like 200 copies total, but according to his research, that same band had being downloaded illegally over 200k times. TorrentFreak dug into it, and after many emails and a long slapfight between TorrentFreak and the record guy. They found out that he was actually being fooled by those fake download scams. Where the website will say that anything you search for have thousands of downloads, just to make you download a malware instead. The record label refused to admit the mistake, went crazy in their own blog accusing TorrentFreak of being the root of all evil. But then when they got hold of the actual band member. They found they were extremely disappointed to find out the downloads were fake. For a few days this completely unknown band thought they were actually famous.
- sallen 14y agoThe article and the headline do not mention it, but FYI, this takes place in the United Kingdom.
- cube13 14y agoCame here to post that. It would be nice to mention it in the title, since it's buried in one of the links to the actual judgements.
- tomku 14y agoGeneric titles get more clicks, because the reader needs to click through and read the article to find out whether they're affected by the ruling. For the most clicks, headlines need to be specific enough to pique your interest, but vague enough that you can't feel satisfied that you know the whole story just from the headline. I can't say whether the submitter consciously considered that or not, but this story's headline is a great example of how well it works.
- rickmb 14y agoYeah, it's really annoying that those foreigners don't clearly state that something doesn't take place in the US. Or isn't that what you actually meant?
- daxelrod 14y agoNo, it's annoying when HN submission titles don't clearly state what jurisdiction articles about law apply to. I would personally have the same objection regardless of the article's nationality.
- cube13 14y agoNo. While I am from the US, it's difficult to tell exactly where in the entire world this court case applies to. If it was clearly stated that this was in the UK in the article, I wouldn't have that much of an issue. Unfortunately, the only way to actually figure out that this was in the UK(as opposed to any of the other Commonwealth states that use similar court systems) was to go to the subsequent articles linked in TFA.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lincolnwebs 14y agoAttempting to figure out the country of origin for every lawsuit, law, and court case referenced on this site is ridiculous. It's difficult to parse it all even if it's clearly denoted, and it rarely is. Please, please add the country of origin to headlines like this.
- semanticist 14y agoThe NLA contributed to the death of a startup I worked for last year (in Edinburgh, although this is a UK-wide issue, Meltwater being an English company). At that time, they wanted £5,000 to not sue us, at least that much again, per quarter, for access to a horrific and incomplete API, plus 12p per link per imprint. Let me repeat that one again: they wanted 12p for every time someone saw a link to their website published by us. And even THEN, the NLA don't actually speak for all newspapers in the UK - News International publications are not licensed, which means that there's no legal path to accessing their content. It's complete nonsense. One friend suggested using bit.ly to shorten the URLs, paying the NLA their 12p once and letting them go after bit.ly (in America) for the rest.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoNews Intl. aren't covered? How ironic, News Intl. publications were some of the first to put up pay walls.