3 ms·
Tell me again how "copyright"/"intellectual property" and free speech are somehow compatible?
by bediger4000 14y ago
Tell me again how "copyright"/"intellectual property" and free speech are somehow compatible?
- pgeorgi 14y agoThey're not, but that "free speech" thing is from a time when copyright didn't matter much.
- chc 14y agoIn America at least, copyright was part of the Constitution before freedom of speech was. You may say that it is now outmoded, or that the current implementation is a horrifying mutation of the original intent, but it's hard to argue that copyright is some late comer whose purpose is to trample our long-cherished freedom of speech.
- bediger4000 14y agoRight, but there was some resistance to "copyright" wasn't there? I mean, Thomas Jefferson was quite against it, on free speech grounds, and only agreed because of the "limited term" thing. Thankfully, Disney and other Immoral MegaCorps have found a way around the "limited term", and the US Supreme Court managed to find a way to agree with that hack, so we've now got "intellectual property" overriding free speech. How long can this go on?
- TheAmazingIdiot 14y agoNot very long, actually. If I want a movie, its easy to get. If I want a CD of music or a song, its easy to get. If I want a program for my OS, its easy to get. If I dont want to pay any money for said virtual goods, they're still easy to get. And we are now, at a decent clip, adding 3d physical goods to the market of 'easy to get'.
- sp332 14y agoSome of the authors of the constitution wanted to add the bill of rights when it was first passed. Others disagreed, and the compromise was to agree to add the bill of rights as a serious of amendments (individually ratified by the states) soon after. But note! The controversy was not whether those rights should be protected, or not. The debate was whether the rights had to be expressly written down, or whether they were obvious enough to go without saying. So the bill of rights was added later because it was considered unnecessary by many of the founders.
- slowpoke 14y agoCopyright is not part of the constitution. That's flat out wrong. What's part of the constitution is congress' ability to create copyright or patent laws. There's absolutely no imperative to have these laws, and as others have pointed out, there was opposition against this power from several founding fathers, including Thomas Jefferson. It strikes me as either uninformed or dishonest to assert/imply that copyright is a constitutionally granted right.
- chc 14y agoBecause this sort of thing is not an intended use case for copyright? You may as well say crowbars are incompatible with free speech because I could hit somebody with one to get him to stop talking. Copyright isn't meant to cover ideas, so it couldn't, in a hypothetical well-functioning system, be used to restrict free speech in a meaningful way.
- imgabe 14y agoIn what way aren't they? "Free speech" as a right is intended to protect your ability to pronounce your original thoughts, which may be unpopular. It protects you from the government silencing you for political reasons. It does not: 1. Require other private citizens to listen to you, or agree with you 2. Require private corporations to broadcast your work or otherwise expend resources to make it available. 3. Give you free license to republish other people's work. I mean, suppose I were to collect all of your Hacker News comments and publish them as "The Collected Works of Bediger4000" without your permission and without compensating you. Do you believe that should be protected as free speech?
- bediger4000 14y agoI don't see how getting Dan Bull to not express his views is not censorship. Perhaps not governmental (in the USA, in other countries, we have "Crown Copyright"). As far as my belief goes, yes, you (and whoever would like to) should collect all of my Hacker News comments, and republish them as widely as possible. I personally don't believe in the legitimacy of the concept of "intellectual property". Independent invention pretty much negates "intellectual property" in my viewpoint, but I also believe that the harm of keeping other people from doing things outweighs any benefits society (or individuals) get from squelching some arbitrary expression. So, collect and publish away! I still have my ideas, and when you distribute them so will many, many others! We all win!
- mcguire 14y agoI suspect the actual question should be, "I mean, suppose I were to collect all of your Hacker News comments and publish them as "The Collected Works of imgabe" without your permission and without compensating you. Do you believe that should be protected as free speech?"
- bediger4000 14y agoA flat "yes". I still stand by my rationale. imgabe didn't "steal" my ideas, I still have them. So do more people, now that the ideas got spread around. imgabe is more than welcome to go to the work of collecting, collating and publishing anything attributed to "bediger4000" on hacker news. The price to society is just too high otherwise. Also, maybe imgabe really did have those ideas, maybe I'm already just copying. But also, what's the harm? imgabe will be discovered as a fraud, when he/she/it/them can't produce any more instantly viral, utterly quotable 3-sentence analyses of difficult situations. Or when someone tries to look up a phrase in Google. imgabe is not bediger4000. I have a natural monopoly on the witticisms of bediger4000.