3 ms·
What's your threat model? What are threat models you would not be comfortable trusting to properly-operationalized PGP?
by tptacek 2y ago
What's your threat model? What are threat models you would not be comfortable trusting to properly-operationalized PGP?
- anotherhue 2y agoTo be fair, "properly operationalised" anything is probably secure, or sensibly degrades when the axioms are up. I think the question is, "what is the cost of properly operationalising" it. TFA mentions frequent manual rekeying as a poor man's PFS. Life is too short for that. (I knew this discussion would summon you like a ghost of crypto past).
- tptacek 2y agoRight, but I'm trying to ask a more interesting question. What are actual real-world security problems where you're comfortable using PGP, and what are some problems where that's not enough for you? As someone else on the thread alluded to: what's missing from a lot of discussion of PGP is "what are you using it for". "Secure email" can't be the answer; what exactly are you emailing?
- shitter 2y agoAnswering that on HN is the final operational security failure listed in the article.
- palata 2y agoOne is messengers. I believe that Signal and similar modern systems (like MLS) do what they do better than PGP, because of forward secrecy. But acknowledging the fact that I receive a lot of emails from a lot of services, it feels like it would be nice if those services had an option to encrypt the emails they send me with PGP. That way my email provider would not have access to their content, right?
- tptacek 2y agoSo the thread model here is transactional emails? Don't modern services solve this problem just by HTTPS-linking back to the service?
- palata 2y ago> Don't modern services solve this problem just by HTTPS-linking back to the service? Not all of them. That's actually a feature in GMail: it will populate your calendar from the information it reads in your confirmation emails, right? I would argue that those modern services that send me a huge HTML-only email that only contains noise and a link to their website are downright annoying. It is very nice to receive a text-only update that contains useful information that I can read offline.