2 ms·
One could look at how colonial America lived. I once toured Washington's home Mount Vernon. He was probably the richest man in America at the time. I wouldn't
by WalterBright 2y ago
One could look at how colonial America lived.
I once toured Washington's home Mount Vernon. He was probably the richest man in America at the time.
I wouldn't prefer his lifestyle, at all.
- krapp 2y agoOne could, but given that such small-scale economies existed within in the modern post-industrial era, it would be disingenuous to do so.
- WalterBright 2y agoBig business drives the prosperity of the economy. Trying to run an economy with mom and pop businesses means poverty.
- krapp 2y agoNo it doesn't, because "poverty" is relative to the scale of an economy. See me, living in a small Texas town and paying $500/mo for an apartment someone in Manhattan would kill to rent for ten times as much. Plenty of people have lived in towns and villages which weren't entirely dominated by big businesses and they got along just fine.
- WalterBright 2y ago> because "poverty" is relative to the scale of an economy If you define poverty as being in the lowest 20% of income, then you can never eliminate poverty. > Plenty of people have lived in towns and villages which weren't entirely dominated by big businesses and they got along just fine. You wouldn't have an internet phone without big business. Nor a car. Nor a washing machine. Nor indoor plumbing. Nor oranges in winter. Nor a hospital. Nor air conditioning. Nor electricity. Nor sanitation. Nor fertilizer. In fact, getting rid of business would result in the death of more than 90% of the population. And likely much more.
- krapp 2y agoAgain, there is an entire spectrum of human existence between medieval subsistence and modern global industrial capitalism, and you seem to be defining literally every trade since the Industrial Revolution as "big business." Either the economy hasn't grown in any significant way over the last century, or clearly it was possible to purchase cars and washing machines, and transport goods, and have hospitals and air conditioning without "big business" of the scale that the context of this thread is clearly referring to. And the ancient Romans had indoor plumbing.
- WalterBright 2y ago> And the ancient Romans had indoor plumbing. Only a handful of rich Romans. > or clearly it was possible to purchase cars and washing machines, and transport goods, and have hospitals and air conditioning without "big business" of the scale that the context of this thread is clearly referring to. Nope. It took Ford's big business to be able to make cars cheap enough for the masses. Before Ford, it was a luxury item for a handful of wealthy people. Railroads were big business, too. You cannot have much of an economy with just horses.
- krapp 2y ago>Only a handful of rich Romans. Yes. And therefore, they didn't need modern industrial capitalism with global corporations to do it. And, just noting the moving goalposts here, your claim wasn't that such amenities weren't affordable without modern capitalism, because even with it, many people struggle to afford them, it was that they were impossible at any scale other than "big business." >It took Ford's big business to be able to make cars cheap enough for the masses. Before Ford, it was a luxury item for a handful of wealthy people. Ford at the time of the Model T wouldn't be considered a "big business" in the modern context. Again, you seem to think any business counts as "big business." Using the same term to refer to Ford in 1910 and, say, Amazon or Wal-Mart today is ridiculous. Obviously Ford would become "big business" but just as obviously Ford is one example of it being possible to manufacture goods at what would be far closer to "mom and pop" scale today.