3 ms·
In addition to his confusion over the clock frequency speedup argument (as pointed out by cultureulterior), PZ Myers doesn't seem to argue from a concrete idea
by jessriedel 14y ago
In addition to his confusion over the clock frequency speedup argument (as pointed out by cultureulterior), PZ Myers doesn't seem to argue from a concrete idea of how detailed a scan will have to be to capture the important brain functions. The feasibility of brain scans is strongly sensitive to the (currently disputed) necessary level of detail. It doesn't make sense for him to say
> We can’t even record the complete state of a single cell;
unless he's just using it as a general statement about out technology. It's completely possible that recording the state of a cell with molecular resolution remains beyond our control even when we can scan brains to the resolution necessary to simulate human cognition.
Also, when I heard that
> With the most elaborate and careful procedures, they report excellent fixation within 5 microns of the surface, and disruption of the tissue by ice crystal formation within 20 microns.
my estimate of brain scan feasibility went up. Of course it's true that we don't yet "have a method to lock down the state of a 3kg brain"; we're discussing the far future!
Pre-WWII, I think someone could have made very similar arguments about computers by pointing out how fast they would have to be to do something crazy like a 3D simulation. By golly, they'd need billions of transistors. Yes, computers are different than brain scanning, so the scalability of one need not imply the scalability of the other. But the point is that you can't just argue "look how hard this is now; it will continue to be hard in the future". You have to argue about why progress in brain scanning will be slow (compared to computers).
- jostmey 14y agoYou will pretty much have to have molecular resolution! There are thousands of (and maybe many orders of magnitude more) different types of ion-channels - the basic unit of electric transmission in neurons. Unless you can identify what types of ion-channels are located throughout the neuron, you will have no hope of reproducing its function.
- kanzure 14y agoHi, you should know about http://channelpedia.epfl.ch/ http://channelpedia.epfl.ch/
- slurgfest 14y agoHow do you propose to translate channelpedia into a complete functional description of an observed brain? Or is the idea to somehow make a working model of the "average" brain inferred from a patchwork of bits of high-level aggregate data mined from various papers and originally gathered in many different contexts?
- kanzure 14y agoyes, that's a good start. also, nothing beats actually algorithmically reconstructing data from image slices http://3scan.com/ http://3scan.com/ or setting up NEURON simulations.
- aidenn0 14y agoI think what the article is pointing out is that: 1) People who have never tried to scan a brain say "oh it's totally doable, why haven't we done this with simple organisms?" 2) People who are actually trying to scan brains say "Um, have you even read any of our papers, we know it would be useful, but it's hard"
- jessriedel 14y ago> People who have never tried to scan a brain say "oh it's totally doable, why haven't we done this with simple organisms?" Who are these people? Certainly not Chris Hallquist in the post linked by Myers. And where does Myers say this? I don't see him attributing to anyone the claim that the scanning of simple organisms should already have happened.