3 ms·
My mental model of how this works --- and I have some (imperfect) evidence for it --- is that a given one of these firms (NSO or one of its competitors) has an
by tptacek 2y ago
My mental model of how this works --- and I have some (imperfect) evidence for it --- is that a given one of these firms (NSO or one of its competitors) has an addressable market of N countries each with an average of K security agencies, and basically all of those agencies pay subscription fees to be continuously in a position to do a CNE operation when they want to.
(Generally, I don't think countries just "buy exploits"; a significant component of the money in this space comes from "maintenance", so much so that I think it makes more sense to think of exploits as subscription services.)
- ghxst 2y ago> so much so that I think it makes more sense to think of exploits as subscription services. I think this makes sense, especially given the uncertainty of when an exploit gets patched. To my original argument of political power vs valuations you can probably say that having those same people you'd otherwise try to influence on your board with a financial incentive allows you to achieve the same thing, I'm not sure why I didn't consider that before.
- tptacek 2y agoDon't get me wrong: I'm sure there's plenty going on between NSO and Israel, and a lot of politics involved. But I also know it to be a real industry, with lots of players.