6 ms·
Don't talk about VCs
- killerdark 14y agoOk.. Let's see if this one gets a front page ban as well.. I'm curious now.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 14y agoOne of the unwritten rules of tech blogging is that you don't write about VCs. Or if you absolutely must, if it's unavoidable, it's always in glowing terms. Do I live in some weird insulated pocket of the Internet, or is this a narrative Winer has just invented for himself to occupy? Or does "Tech blogger" have a different meaning to him?
- michaelochurch 14y agoI think his definition of "tech blogger" includes "...who wants VC investment in the future."
- tptacek 14y agoHow many people have ever not gotten a VC investment because of the way they wrote about VCs? If the numbers make sense to them, VCs will invest. If anything, from how I understand it, VCs use social signals in exactly the opposite direction: people who are overly nice to them are not alphas.
- michaelochurch 14y agoWell, I don't think that the OP is advising people never to write "about VCs" so much as he's commenting on the groupthink and tendency to protect their own and remarking that, therefore, a person who exposes one bad apple will offend them all. I've heard of people having trouble raising money because they blew whistles on unethical VC practices from unrelated investors. The problem is that VCs all talk to each other and compare notes far beyond what any reasonable person would consider appropriate.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm using this comment to again dispute the idea that writing nice things about VCs will help you score a round, or that writing mean things about them will prevent you from doing that. They certainly do compare notes, but they're way more afraid of losing out on a good deal (remember: one good outcome pays for much of the portfolio) than they are interested in swinging their dicks. They're comparing notes to see if the others in herd view the company as an alpha. Not to blackball people who write negative things about VCs in the abstract.
- slurgfest 14y agoJob-seekers are always advised not to be negative about past employers. In other situations it is considered prudent to avoid this kind of talk, and I think it is strongly against norms of American business. I am sure that most of the best classical artists had to watch their tongues around patrons. So I'm interested to know: how is it really different with VCs?
- tptacek 14y agoThe VC/company relationship is really not at all like an employer/employee relationship. It would probably be very bad form and inadvisable to write something nasty about a VC you had worked with directly. But otherwise, we're talking about what is by necessity a highly mercenary part of the market.
- andyl 14y ago"The VC/company relationship is really not at all like an employer/employee relationship." They can fire you, and you can't fire them. That means you are the employee, and they are the employer. If everything goes great, you'll never have to put that relationship to the test. But things don't always go great...
- tptacek 14y agoIf you're an early stage company, the pre-revenue kind that we tend to think about when we talk about VCs on HN, the VC is buying a stake in 2-4 years of your output when they invest in you. Sure, they can "fire" you, in the sense that they often have the ability to vote you out of the company you founded, but this is usually a loss for them, not a win; they staked you, and you end up walking. Anyways, the number of instances we can cite of a VC removing an officer of a company because they were discovered to have written mean things about VC in the abstract is... let me go out on a limb here...
- michaelochurch 14y agoI don't have any reason to like or dislike VCs on personal experience. The ones I've met randomly (e.g. running in Central Park) seem to be nice enough, and I'm sure that a lot of them are good. But VC-istan is full of deeply unethical people (those I have met, unfortunately) who don't deserve to be funded and I can't believe that the VCs aren't aware of what these people are doing. VCs need to stop funding unethical people, who get money just because they're well-connected, outright. Plus there are horrors like multiple liquidation preferences, which exist to reassert the social superiority of the VCs and leave me feeling it wouldn't be so bad if VC-Istan disappeared. Technology doesn't need it.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI don't have any reason to like or dislike VCs on personal experience. The ones I've met randomly (e.g. running in Central Park) seem to be nice enough, and I'm sure that a lot of them are good. But VC-istan is full of deeply unethical people (those I have met, unfortunately) who don't deserve to be funded and I can't believe that the VCs aren't aware of what these people are doing. VCs need to stop funding unethical people, just because they're well-connected, outright. Plus there are horrors like multiple liquidation preferences, which exist to reassert the social superiority of the VCs and leave me feeling it wouldn't be so bad if VC-Istan disappeared. Technology doesn't need it.
- marcusf 14y agoMay be tangential, but I've been reading Dave Winer off and on for several years, and I always have such a hard time figuring out why he feels so slighted? Either he suffers from a serious martyr complex, there's a grand conspiracy going around to hinder his greatness from blooming or I've simply never grown accustomed to his slightly boastful writing (seriously, the ratio of blog posts where he mentions he invented RSS should be the basis for a measure like the Winer Self-Aggrandizement Index or WSAI).
- shareme 14y agoas member of the select DaveWinerNumber club I humbly suggest you Google DaveWinerNumber..my earning of said number was by DW asking for my phone number to debate a post :)
- monochromatic 14y ago> like the American workers who Romney's tactics cost their jobs and pensions Wait, what??
- staunch 14y agoVirtually every great tech company was built with the help of VCs. Google, Amazon, Facebook, Reddit, Twitter, Yelp, etc. The alternatives to these companies winning was not an open solution run by a co-op of hippies. The alternative was some shittier solution by Microsoft, MySpace, Yahoo, or even nothing at all. It really might be nicer if The Search Engine (Google), The Message Broadcasting Platform (Twitter), The Social Platform (Facebook) were NOT run by private companies, with all their faults and biases. It would be better for the world if every person and company could build on them in a completely competitive and fair way. We would get better stuff. It just doesn't seem to work out that way. Either people aren't motivated to do it or it's not possible. Whatever the case it's just not how things work (for now). Given the way it does work VCs contribute in a very important way. Their effect seems to be purely additive. They don't prevent anyone from succeeding by alternative means. Mitt Romney seems like a very different kind of VC than helped tech companies. He handled much later stage stuff (IIRC), making him more of an investment banker type.