3 ms·
The problem is the conflation of security and identity. You need security to guarantee identity, but not the other way around. I see no reason that we can't hav
by jedberg 14y ago
The problem is the conflation of security and identity. You need security to guarantee identity, but not the other way around. I see no reason that we can't have encrypted connections without identity.
Ssh has basically solved this. If you're like 99% of ssh users, you just accept the key the server gave you without verification. Your browser could do the same on the web -- just accept the server certificate and then indicate to you that the connection is secure but the servers identity is not verified.
This solves pretty much all the issues you bring up.
And if http 2 required it,then even better, because all the server would support it and all the clients would too.
- emmett 14y agoThat solution simply does not work. If your browser will accept the certificate that the server presents, anyone can pretend to be anyone and your browser will accept it. Enforcing identity is just as important as encrypting the connection. You can do that identity enforcement through some scheme (accept-first-time, or web-of-trust, or something else) but they all have significant downsides. It's not an easy problem.
- jedberg 14y ago> If your browser will accept the certificate that the server presents, anyone can pretend to be anyone and your browser will accept it. Yes but at least the data is protected from eavesdroppers that don't control any hardware in the line of the connection, which is better than nothing.
- jasomill 14y agoMost browsers let you accept a particular certificate for a particular site already, just like SSH, so you can already have this if you want. Part of the reason it works so well for SSH, though, is "security through unpopularity": you don't have large numbers of naïve users doing online banking at Starbucks over SSH. If SSH became more popular, you'd need to verify the fingerprint, and then you're back to square one ("If I have a secure channel with which to verify the identity of the SSH key, why not just use this same channel to establish the secure session?").
- jedberg 14y agoExcept that if I want to accept a self signed certificate I have to click 6 times through scary warning screens. And that is a good thing because that cert is for both encryption and identity. If it were JUST for encryption, there'd be no issue just auto accepting that certificate.