4 ms·
I'm not so sure - a standard definition is "acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group." I gue
by tim333 2y ago
I'm not so sure - a standard definition is "acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group."
I guess you can call civilian casualties fighting terrorists and restricting food that but it detracts from the use of the term for real round them up and kill them all type genocides.
And then you'd wonder if things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Dresden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Dresden count as genocide. And then if you use it like that it kind of loses its meaning if all war is genocide.
I note the title of this HN story is basically a lie. That wasn't the title of the linked article, or it's content. The article says what they have seen could be consistent with genocide, not "declares the war in Gaza as genocide." It specifically says they are not declaring it a genocide as they feel they don't have the legal expertise.
- aguaviva 2y agoAnd then you'd wonder if things like the bombing of Dresden count as genocide. Yup, that's exactly what it was. A "mini" one, granted, perhaps 5 percent (if we count all the other terror bombings conducted by the Allies - Dresden was but one of many) the size of the vastly larger genocide perpetrated by the Nazis. But there's little point in arguing that that's what the deliberate targetting of civilian populations in Germany (both during and after the war, considering the mass expulsions that followed) did not effectively amount to a "mini" genocide, nonetheless. And then if you use it like that it kind of loses its meaning if all war is genocide. No, pointing out this fairly obvious fact does not, by any stretch, imply that "all war" is genocide. Only the large-scale, deliberate targeting of civilian populations "with intent to destroy [them] as a group, in whole or in part", per the definition above. That wasn't the title of the linked article, or it's content. That's a valid point, and indeed the article should probably be flagged on that basis.
- tim333 2y agoI get what you are saying and it's about definitions of words but if you go that way you get so yeah the Nazi's committed genocide but so did their opponents so it doesn't really matter. Maybe we need a new term for excessive killing of civilians but short of trying to wipe out a whole people.
- aguaviva 2y agoBut if you go that way you get so yeah the Nazi's committed genocide but so did their opponents so it doesn't really matter. I don't think that follows. In terms of implying the "so they're all basically the same, and the distinction doesn't really matter" part. On its own terms, the definition just doesn't do that. Granted, some (many) people might think that way, but I think that's a subset of the broader problem of people being hopelessly caught up in muddled thinking patterns generally, these days. Maybe we need a new term for excessive killing of civilians but short of trying to wipe out a whole people. "Partial genocide," "smaller-scale", "mini" etc would seem to do the trick. But unfortunately boring language of that sort doesn't trigger people's dopamine levels, and so content discussing recent events in these more measured tones doesn't get promoted and shared as often. (BTW, the genocide definition under discussion refers not just to "excessive" killings of civilians, but the specific targeting of civilians of a particular group. If the Allies had only targeted military facilities, even with the greatly more imprecise munitions in use at the time, then it would be much more difficult to say that these bombings were "genocidal". It's the fact that the Allies deliberately targeted residential areas, at a massive scale and with the specific intent of spreading terror in the civilian population, which made these bombings arguably genocidal).
- afiori 2y agoThis is seeing the morality of the situation upside down: Committing genocide is bad, whether it's by your enemy, ally, or you own does not change that. If you allow I would like to rephrase your conclusion differently > The Nazis committed genocide but so did the USA, the USSR, the CCCP so they should not act all high and mighty as a paragon of morality.
- p3rls 2y agoIncorrect -- the "genocide" in Dresden killed only 20,000 germans but helped the war effort for the allies -- preventing our causalities and mitigating further nazi atrocities (auschwitz alone was almost doubling that 20k kill count each week btw). Of course the efficacy of the raid is another matter. It was a "good genocide"
- thenaturalist 2y ago> Only the large-scale, deliberate targeting of civilian populations "with intent to destroy [them] as a group, in whole or in part", per the definition above. So given you so much care about "mini" details, surely you would admit that the latest Hamas attack where so many anihilated villages close to the Gaza strip, killing Israeli Jews and Arabs alike as well as several foreigners, killing babies, women and the elderly indiscriminately, burning buildings and taking hostages is, by your own definition, very much to be considered to be a genocide?
- aguaviva 2y agoSurely you would admit ... You know, you could have asked your question in a normal, straightforward manner -- e.g. "Would you say the Oct 7th attack was also genocidal in nature, per these criteria?" -- and you would have gotten a straightforward answer. But as it is, you've chosen a weird, pretentious way of formulating your question. So I'll have to pass, and let you think whatever you want to think.
- thenaturalist 2y agoWe’re on a public discussion forum. Always telling to see people bring these elaborate details to the forefront instead of simply stating where they stand if it’s about Jewish life.
- aguaviva 2y agoYour framing was disingenuous, straight up -- it was a baiting question in the classic mold -- and that's why it was necessary to shut it down. When you start a question with "Surely you will admit ...", it presupposes a certain aura of doubt or guilt on the part of the person that you're addressing (as if you think there's grounds to believe they would be reluctant to give a normal, sensible answer to that question). You also buttered up your inquest with excessive detail, as if you thought the person you were addressing it to would be ignorant of (or in denial about) the events of that day. No one needs to answer questions like this. Always telling to see ... I find the bullshit insinuation of antisemitism that you're making here (on a public discussion forum, no less) to be rather insulting, actually.
- afiori 2y agoGenocide as defined in international law is very broad, it also includes cases where 0 people are killed: - displacing a group in a wider region to try and dilute the ethnicity/culture is genocide - trying to increase infertility in a group can be genocide - forcing children from a group to attend schooling of another culture can be genocide Any action or set of actions that causes going from condition "this cultural/ethnic/national group exists in some state" to condition "the same group is has suffered irreparable damage" can be genocide if done with that objective. For example when Canada was sending Native American children to boarding school it was clearly a genocidal act, the only uncertainty would be around the intentions: 1) if the Canadian government was trying to improve the standard of education and literacy then it wasn't a genocide 2) if they were trying to bring some good old Christianity to new continent pagans then it was genocide. In general forced boarding school of a minority definitely would sound like genocide. You can guess how starving a country while bombing it to scraps scores on this scale
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Jensson 2y agoSo we watered down the term, gotcha, now we know declaring things a genocide doesn't mean anything any longer. The boy who cried wolf and all that.
- tdeck 2y agoRaphael Lemkin, the person who invented the term Genocide, also helped craft its definition in international law. The Rome Convention was based on his proposals, so the idea that his own definition of the term that he created "waters it down" is simply ignorant.
- afiori 2y agoWe correctly expected future governments to occasionally want to get rid of undesirable ethic groups and created a definition that would leave them a few loopholes as possible. If genocide was "kill more than half of a population" or "kill more than 100k people" it would be easy to erase minorities simply by forced sterilization. The Genocide convention was not created to stop people from dying it was created to stop entire populations from dying out.
- okokhacker 2y ago> round them up and kill them all type genocides. You’re implying that this doesn’t happen already in Gaza. https://news.sky.com/story/footage-shows-palestinians-blindfolded-and-led-away-by-israeli-soldiers-in-northern-gaza-13239750 https://news.sky.com/story/footage-shows-palestinians-blindf... I’m sure you can search this up yourself, but I think your goal with this thread is deflection.
- edanm 2y ago1. I'm going to state outright that I don't think rounding up Palestinian civilians and shooting them is happening. Israel does a lot of things I disagree with and there are, I'm sure, many war crimes being committed, but rounding people up and shooting them is far, far away from anything anyone has any proof for (or any reason to think is happening). 2. While you seem to imply that your article proves the opposite, it doesn't - it just shows Palestinians being "rounded up", or as the IDF says, arrested. There is no reason to think (that I saw) that this is anything other than a mass arrest of Palestinians, possibly terrorists, possibly civilians that are sometimes arrested and later released. If you think literally any picture of the IDF arresting many people is proof that those people are killed, then I understand why you're sure that the IDF is going around killing Palestinian civilians.
- okokhacker 2y agoHuh. The bar of proof for the IDF to be rounding up and killing people is so high, but you’re quick to suggest that the people they round up are likely terrorists. In any case, here you go https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/04/1148876 https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/04/1148876
- edanm 2y ago> Huh. The bar of proof for the IDF to be rounding up and killing people is so high, but you’re quick to suggest that the people they round up are likely terrorists. Yes. This exactly captures my thoughts. The bar for proving that the IDF is committing this kind of crime is pretty high. And yes, I think the IDF is generally trying to arrest terrorists, hence my thinking that if they detained a bunch of people, they are possibly terrorists. I think what is likely happening is that a bunch of people were arrested because they were in a zone where the IDF can't know if they are militants or not, they will be investigated, and most will be released. That's what almost always happens. You, on the other hand, seem to think that if the IDF is detaining a bunch of people, it's in order to mass execute them, despite there being no actual evidence of this ever happening. There are a lot of problems people have with that the IDF is doing, and there's a lot of credible reasons to think war crimes are being committed, but as far as I know, mass detaining and execution of random civilians is not something anybody says is actually happening. > In any case, here you go https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/04/1148876 https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/04/1148876 Once again, a lot of insinuation with very little actual proof. The IDF alleged, and there are credible reasons to think it's true, afaik, that those are just Palestinian graves, not people killed by the IDF. Look, I understand we have different prior beliefs about what is likely here. For an Israeli, I am relatively far left and relatively distrustful of both the IDF and the Israeli government. I think that much of the conduct of Israel is deeply immoral, very possibly war crimes, and I'm fairly certain that multiple cases of war crimes have been committed by some soldiers, though not as a matter of policy. That all said, the things you (and many people) are saying are very implausible. Israel is so often portrayed as evil with absolutely no merit, that Israelis barely pay attention to it anymore, which is not good for anyone.