3 ms·
You can make an example that will invalidate any technology choice. Design for the requirements you have. "That's a very nice car you've made. Unfortunately, i
by xnx 2y ago
You can make an example that will invalidate any technology choice. Design for the requirements you have.
"That's a very nice car you've made. Unfortunately, if the designer later decides that it needs to survive artillery rounds, you'll wish you had built it out of armor steel as I recommended in the first place."
- exe34 2y agoYAGNI should be tattooed on some people's eyelids.
- ASalazarMX 2y agoOn the outside of their eyelids it would do nothing for self-awareness, so I'm assuming written on the inside... which they won't be able to see unless they look at something super bright, like the sun, with their eyes closed. ... I guess this season some of us have more time to overthink things. Still, YAGNI needs careful consideration. What looks like YAGNI right now might be reasonable flexibility that will be needed as the project matures. YAGNI makes perfect sense when delivering a proof of concept, but it's not that straightforward when designing for long-term use.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- juunpp 2y agoAs if requirements are set in stone. The parent comment is a bit exaggerated but it still has a point. One needs to be able to predict things and make sure whatever you do today isn't so rigid that it can't adapt to other things in the future without a major overhaul. Typically this means being cognizant of the assumptions made along the way, and making the minimal set of them. This kind of insight requires experience. People preaching YAGNI just don't seem to have much of it. They just read "YAGNI" in a blog post and then yell it at other people.
- xnx 2y agoI agree no one should follow recommendations blindy, but I have seen WAY more instances (firsthand and second-hand) of people mis-architecting for circumstances that never come. When it comes time to make a change, it's often not as big a deal as it was made out to be, and you have the benefit of everything that has been learned along the way. No one gets it right the first time anyway, so don't overthink it.
- reverius42 2y agoThe requirements you have today are a lot more set in stone than the requirements you don't have today, that you imagine you might have tomorrow.