4 ms·
> "Is this a serious question" is hard to take as anything but an insult. So is "I, as a non-photographer, openly question the utility of this pro-photographer
by ceejayoz 2y ago
> "Is this a serious question" is hard to take as anything but an insult.
So is "I, as a non-photographer, openly question the utility of this pro-photographer tool to pro-photographers", though.
- zamadatix 2y agoHmm, I have no trouble finding "Can you not... I'm no photographer but it seems like it'd be tough" type questions as genuine curiosity about an expert field instead. It's certainly possible to interpret it as an insult if one likes, that's often an easy task, but it definitely feels like it's not the only way to interpret the question.
- spiderice 2y agoHard disagree. A person who is ignorant in a certain subject is allowed to ask questions about that subject in order to learn. > Can you not get this capability with... Can be interpreted as "this is pointless.. you can do this other thing for way cheaper" OR "help me understand why this exists because I don't understand it". GP is _clearly_ in the latter camp and saying "as a non-photographer" to make that clear. Since we're already quoting HN guidelines > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith
- rowanG077 2y agoEven after they were told it has a ton of value add. It indeed irked me the wrong way and that's why I took that tone.