4 ms·
> and there won't be a rebound Why are you confident of this? There's plenty of small high-fertility sub-populations, why not just assume they'll become domin
by ben_w 2y ago
> and there won't be a rebound
Why are you confident of this?
There's plenty of small high-fertility sub-populations, why not just assume they'll become dominant?
Dunbar's number is small, suggests that the influence of society doesn't need to be considered at the level of an entire nation or even an entire city.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y agoThose small high-fertility clusters are still embedded in society as a whole. Their kind are converted at a far quicker rate than they can make kids. The Duggars won't have 400+ grandchildren, for instance, despite having 20+ of their own. The Amish, for instance, though somewhat insulated from the "conversion", buy and use John Deere tractors. What happens when the rest of the world is gone, do you think they'll start building them in factories for themselves? (And if they did, would their fertility remain high?) Yeh, confidence above 90%.
- ben_w 2y ago> Those small high-fertility clusters are still embedded in society as a whole. Their kind are converted at a far quicker rate than they can make kids. The Duggars won't have 400+ grandchildren, for instance, despite having 20+ of their own. Some are as you say. Some are more insular, don't want to mix with everyone else. Some groups are less well defined, because rather than being a named group it's a heritable trait for taking more risks. > What happens when the rest of the world is gone, do you think they'll start building them in factories for themselves? If everything collapsed around them overnight, rapture/left behind style, so that they didn't have a chance to simply displace everyone else over a few generations in the way I'm actually expecting given the population is currently still going up despite the falling fertility, then they'd probably have problems — but even then they'd likely be able to make something like a 1750s era blacksmith making horseshoes and ploughs without huge difficulty.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago>but even then they'd likely be able to make something like a 1750s era blacksmith They don't mine ore. Once they've scavenged all the scrap, they couldn't make nails. That probably wouldn't be the biggest disadvantage though... they couldn't make much of any manufactured good, and their lifestyle depends on it. Whatever institutional knowledge they had for how to live in the 18th century is long gone. When they're back to a single-row iron plow pulled behind draft animals, they're not going to be getting 70 bushels of wheat per acre, they'll be getting 10. And then they won't be able to feed large numbers. None of what they do now works if our society fails, they need us. And they don't know how to do things they way they used to do, either.
- ben_w 2y ago> They don't mine ore. Once they've scavenged all the scrap, they couldn't make nails. All rusty metal is indistinguishable from high-quality ore. They'll only "run out" when all the rust finally washes into the oceans. And even then, iron-rich bacteria are where John Plant (the Primitive Technology guy) gets his small quantities, and he starts many of his videos at the level of showing the stick he uses to dig the clay out of the ground to build the furnace in which he bakes the pot he uses to collect and concentrate the bacteria: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primitive_Technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primitive_Technology Before that becomes necessary, current production of the metal (not just the ore) is around the gigaton/year level, so there's going to be a lot of scrap to get through. > That probably wouldn't be the biggest disadvantage though... they couldn't make much of any manufactured good, and their lifestyle depends on it. Whatever institutional knowledge they had for how to live in the 18th century is long gone. Even if there was a literally overnight displacement, which there won't be, libraries with printed texts still exist. > And then they won't be able to feed large numbers. What do you mean by "large numbers"? At a minimum, 791 million — because that's what we actually did feed in 1750. That's not "extinction". That's not even close to extinction. And that's without any assumptions about any modern knowledge that could be applied to low-industrial society, such as knowing how cholera is transmitted in order to prevent it.
- FrustratedMonky 2y ago
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoIt would be more accurate to say that 'a rebound is difficult'. Not extinct or impossible. With smaller number, are smaller breading opportunities. So after the population collapse, yes, humans will still exist. But might take hundreds of years again to reach our current population levels, and in the interim, societies would have gone through huge upheavals.
- ben_w 2y agoSure, but I'd say mere hundreds of years is brief, almost but not quite negligible, on the scale of human history — the Greek dark ages was about 400 years long.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoYou are Correct. Just sometimes I hear people on the 'right' say we don't really need to take action on X,Y,Z problems, because humans will adapt, and we've been around for thousands of years, so we are really just over-reacting. They ignore that, yeah, humans will be here on a geologic scale, but the US wont, Congress wont, Constitution wont, we're going to collapse into a bunch of warring city states, and where is their precious outrage then? It wont matter if they believed it was all a hoax, when they are dead, but we'll all be dead. So discussing time scales in short term, <100 years is important. Generally, for planning.
- ben_w 2y agoFor personal planning I'd make it much shorter than a century: in one decade I bought my first home, lost both parents, Brexit happened, I moved country, Covid triggered lockdowns worldwide, and Russia invaded Ukraine. But even on the timescale of 2100 — and 75 years was enough time to go from the height of the British Empire to what is widely considered to be its final end in the form of handing back Hong Kong, so quite reasonable to guess the US will be gone by then — only the most extreme forecasts have a lower global population than today.