Your criticism of the title would be more credible if you also acknowledged the point he was making. As it stands you came across as dismissing the entire artic

Your criticism of the title would be more credible if you also acknowledged the point he was making. As it stands you came across as dismissing the entire article as stupid. And I wonder if the hyperbole in the title is really link bait, or just the opposite, troll bait. I'm not sure the title helped the article's ranking on HN.