4 ms·
USDA locks barn door after Listeria escapes
- bee_rider 2y ago> By the time the outbreak had ended, the agency documented 61 cases in 19 states. Sixty of the victims were hospitalized. > Ten people died. […] > Information released by the FSIS in response to multiple Freedom of Information Requests revealed that the agency had been aware of major deficiencies at the Boar’s Head production facility since October 2022, but had taken no action to suspend production or order a clean-up. These deficiences were described as posing an “imminent threat to product” in a Food Safety Assessment conducted in September/October 2022. I guess if the FDA was aware of this, the company must have been as well, right? Hospital bills are quite expensive nowadays, is there any caselaw on trying to recover the costs of medical bills incurred by the sanitation policies of Boar’s Head?
- wyager 2y agoExposing food manufacturers to widespread civil suits like this would surely depress domestic production of food just as opening up fabric manufacturers to fire-related civil suits (e.g. Chapman v Brown) destroyed domestic fabric production. Even if the manufacturer wins 99% of the time, the proliferation of suits like this is sufficiently costly to force production overseas. You still end up with the same (or greater) risks, but the system routes around the legal friction by reducing production in the costly legal regime.
- JadeNB 2y ago> Exposing food manufacturers to widespread civil suits like this would surely depress domestic production of food just as opening up fabric manufacturers to fire-related civil suits destroyed domestic fabric production. "Requiring safe standards is bad for business" is possibly true (at least in the short term), but I'm not sure that the alternative is better. EDIT: I inadvertently read the parent post uncharitably, as suggesting that there should be no enforcement at all. gizmodo (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42452514 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42452514) points out that arguing against civil liability is not arguing against effective regulation and enforcement.
- wyager 2y agoIt's more efficient to treat food safety standards as a criminal matter rather than a civil matter. If it's frequently treated as a civil matter, it results in endless (and endlessly costly) civil suits. The standards for successfully pursuing a civil judgement have to be extremely high in situations like this to discourage destructive ambulance-chasing.
- throwaway48476 2y agoNo. Treating everything like a criminal matter gets you Italy. It didn't actually fix anything because the process is reactive not proactive.
- n4r9 2y agoThe EU mandates testing of food products, monitoring of farms and processing facilities, and enforces strict trade controls on potentially contaminated products. This works just fine and drastically reduces disease due to pathogens such as Salmonella relative to the US.
- throwaway48476 2y agoA lot of the EU relies on basically slave labor for agriculture so I'm not inclined to believe that everything is universally enforced, especially on the periferry.
- n4r9 2y agoWe can look at the number of infections per year to quantify the effectiveness of the regulations. In the US there are approx 1.35 million per year [0], i.e. 1 in 255 people, with around 450 deaths. In the EU there are approx 70k reported cases [1] i.e. 1 in 6500, with around 90 deaths. Moreover the number of cases drastically dropped in the EU since regulations came into force earlier this century. The data here is very clear that regulations save lives. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/salmonella/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/salmonella/index.html [1] https://www.cdc.gov/salmonella/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/salmonella/index.html
- parsimo2010 2y agoI think there is a way to distinguish between blanket liability any time someone gets sick eating your product, and suing Boar's Head for continuing to operate with deficiencies that were documented in a report and known to the company. It is regrettable that the FSIS did not enforce harder, but I think someone who's family died because of this should be able to sue.
- everforward 2y ago> I think there is a way to distinguish between blanket liability any time someone gets sick eating your product, and suing Boar's Head for continuing to operate with deficiencies that were documented in a report and known to the company. I would generally expect the latter to be accomplished by regulatory fines; it's simpler and cleaner than an array of individual civil suits. The greater issue is that I'd be very surprised if many of those civil suits were effective, and especially so for being cost effective (for either side). Citizens will need to prove beyond a preponderance of evidence that their relative's infection was due to Boar's Head, which is going to be very difficult. Everyone is exposed to dozens of potential Listeria sources every day; it's hard to prove it was Boar's Head and not Chipotle or McDonald's or whatever else they've eaten/touched. It genuinely probably makes more sense to do a regulatory fine on Boar's Head, and then distribute the fine to affected people via a mechanism with a lower bar. Maybe everyone who had a Listeria infection around that time, which is much easier to prove than the source of the infection.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoYour understanding of how liability works is flawed. Manufacturing products overseas doesn't exempt you from liability for selling t-shirts that are too flammable. I can still sue The Gap for selling me a dangerous item that they made in Bangladesh as easily as I can sue them for selling me a dangerous item that they made in San Francisco.
- wyager 2y agoAnd yet manufacturer liability was a significant causal factor in domestic textile production collapsing
- QuercusMax 2y agoMaking sure they employees don't all die in horrendous fires is why US textile production collapsed? Do you have a citation for that? Because that sounds insane. I thought it moved overseas because they can pay children pennies, not because they literally want to roast their peons alive.
- nickff 2y agoI linked to the cited case in my comment; it's an interesting read, and I suggest that you check it out https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42452760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42452760
- dghlsakjg 2y agoThe suit you cited happened in 1961. However, in the 1950s every domestic textile category had seen at least double digit declines (97% for wool!), while imports had seen triple digit growth (cotton fabric imports tripled). The industry was already well on its way to failure, so I have a hard time believing there is a causal relationship. As I stated before, the liability still exists even when you manufacture outside of the country. There are no net cost savings from a liability lawsuit standpoint to be had by moving production overseas.
- dehrmann 2y ago
- bee_rider 2y agoI think it would be really hard to show causation there; I’d expect, at least, that higher wages and higher regulation would be pretty correlated (more well off populations might be less willing to sacrifice lives to industry). Maybe the fabric industry moved out because American workers weren’t cost-competitive.
- nickff 2y ago> "Maybe the fabric industry moved out because American workers weren’t cost-competitive." That seems like a likely factor, but insurance against product liability suits can be very expensive in some (litigious) industries, and is also a factor in total cost analysis.
- dec0dedab0de 2y agoThe obvious answer is to find a way to open up overseas production to the risk of being sued. Perhaps putting all liability on the importer, distributor, or retailer for imported goods.
- nickff 2y ago> "Perhaps putting all liability on the importer, distributor, or retailer for imported goods." These parties do carry extensive liabilities when there's a product defect or fault, as was the case in the cited case. The issue is that manufacturers usually produce larger volumes, and are thus vulnerable to more of these lawsuits, as well as class-actions. Class-action cases are often extremely and expensive, even when there was no clear fault.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> Perhaps putting all liability on the importer, distributor, or retailer for imported goods. Standard product liability law already has joint and several liability for manufacturing defects on all parties in the chain of commerce, so each of the retailer, distributor, importer, and manufacturer already bear full liability.
- Etheryte 2y agoIf you produce food without meeting the bare minimum standard of don't make people sick then your operation absolutely should get, as you say, depressed.
- nickff 2y agoThe problem is that there are a lot of spurious and dubious cases, and class-actions are very expensive and risky to defend, even when the defendant is innocent, largely because they're seen as unsympathetic 'piggy-banks' (whereas the plaintiffs are often very sympathetic).
- nickff 2y agoThanks for the citation of 'Chapman v Brown', it's an interesting case that I hadn't heard of: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/198/78/1671808/ https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/1...
- michaelmrose 2y agoIt seems much harder to move meat production overseas. You can use destructively high tariffs to prevent it. You can also require imports to follow the same standards including domestic inspection. Any suits that fail 99% of the time are frivilous and the normal method of dealing with same is punishing claimants who should have known better by fining and disbarring lawyers and making claimant bear costs. Ways exist to distinguish between a frivilous and non case in this category. -Has responsible party exhibited a pattern of failures of their normal duty of care according to testimony and evidence that would be collected by the government as part of reasonable investigations and inspection -Is it more likely than not that present issue is related. It seems unreasonable that we must either open up bobs meats to lawsuits with every sandwich or ignore the fact that Bob killed dozens because he has been known to be a filthy pig for years.
- ApolloFortyNine 2y agoHas it actually come out why "imminent threat to product" for over a year didn't result in a shut down? I know this is a popular topic to blame Trump on for some reason (happening 2 years into the next admin), but surely the fda still has the ability to shut down locations some times. My gut is it just got lost in the bureaucracy of the agency, but I'd love to see an actual explanation.
- boringg 2y agoGet DOGE to examine the failures.
- digdugdirk 2y agoExamining failures isn't very efficient. Probably best to just carry on as is, nothing we can do.
- groby_b 2y agoAs if DOGE had any competency at that. Most of their proposals are deeply flawed because they didn't bother to dig into details - not the behavior you want when examining failures.
- bee_rider 2y agoI have no idea, it seems quite weird that they weren’t made to shut down. What’s Trump have to do with? I don’t like him or his policies, but I don’t think we need to trace all bad decisions back to him or anything like that.
- lukan 2y ago"What’s Trump have to do with?" I suppose because he cut spending on government work in general, that is not police and army related? (But I lack insights into whether he cut any budgets related to this)
- readthenotes1 2y ago
- nicholasjarnold 2y agotl;dr No barn doors were actually locked. A series of protocol changes are suggested to specifically address listeria bacteria in food processing plants. Also, conjecture: Closing a barn door would likely not solve any actual food safety issues, but it might keep the livestock in place.
- lostlogin 2y agoI might be missing a joke, but if not, there is a saying ‘closing/shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted’. It’s used in a context where someone has acted too late. https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/104948/english-proverb-for-when-a-solution-comes-too-late https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/104948/english-p...
- vel0city 2y agoLocking the barn door after the previous (and now incoming) administration opened them. https://www.usda.gov/article/usda-announces-proposed-rule-modernize-swine-inspection https://www.usda.gov/article/usda-announces-proposed-rule-mo... This is just the natural result of these policies. Did they really expect the companies to actually self-report all the deficiencies?
- MrMcCall 2y agoNo, they have removed regulations so that their cronies can capitalize on our lack of power.
- declan_roberts 2y agoWe're going to need better ideas and solutions other than "but Trump"
- specialist 2y agoPreviously, TX Gov GWB instituted self reporting for air pollution, followed up by POTUS GWB creating OSHA's Voluntary Protection Program to do the same for labor and safety. It played out as you'd expect.
- frgtpsswrdlame 2y agoI thought the issue was deregulation? Something like Trump rolled back some rules about oversight and then Biden never put them back into place? Does the USDA even have the power to fix this? Anyways, having a pregnant wife right now, it's worrying that listeria is on the rise. We're already avoiding stuff like deli meat but when there's listeria in the frozen waffles, mushrooms, and vegetables you have to wonder what's really going on.
- throwaway48476 2y agoThe USDA created the problem through regulating industry consolidation. The 'fix' is to reconfigure the economy to price in unpriced negative externalities and create sustainable industries. This of course won't happen.
- mft_ 2y agoI’m struggling to understand what you are advocating for in practice. What was such a reconfiguration of the economy actually mean in real terms?
- arrosenberg 2y agoHe's pointing out that meat packing consolidated into a cartel (Tyson, JBS, Smithfield and Cargill), which has enough economic power to ignore or alter regulation. The solution is antitrust - break corporate power into small enough pieces that they don't have the resources to escape regulatory oversight.
- throwaway48476 2y agoThat's absolutely part of it. Animals that are kept close together in cages and barns instead of roaming get sick and spread sickness far more quickly as well. We've created a million dangerous biolabs for diseases with biosimilarity to us.
- throwaway48476 2y ago
- throwaway48476 2y agoThe US meat industry cartel does not value safety. It's not priced in.
- latchkey 2y agoIt is a global issue. Ever been to SE Asia and eaten street food?
- throwaway48476 2y ago[flagged]
- mft_ 2y agoA data point on this: post-Brexit the UK Government has been doing their best to agree trade deals with countries around the globe. There is (for obvious reasons) significant interest in a trade deal with the United States, but a big fear (often mentioned when this topic crops up) is that the UK would be forced to accept apparently substandard quality US beef as part of the deal.
- throwaway48476 2y ago'substandard' is often trotted out but rarely defined.
- ada1981 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 2y agoMeat safety is a USDA thing, not FDA. It doesn't make sense, but this is only an FDA failure in that they didn't try to move in on USDA's territory.
- dralley 2y agoThere are some ways in which it would perhaps make sense to rethink the traditional boundaries of these regulatory organizations. Why should food regulation responsibilities be split up between the FDA and USDA? Why not have a cleaner separation between food and drug regulations? Why are ATF and DEA separate organizations, but human trafficking falls under the FBI?
- ada1981 2y agoThis is more general in the sense of failing with MDMA and enabling the opioid crisis.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoWow, that's a lot of effort for the same government that's about to remove the requirement or even try to ban the polio vaccine.
- RandallBrown 2y agoIt's not the same government. Trump isn't President and RFK Jr. isn't the secretary of health... yet.
- tzs 2y ago> Information released by the FSIS in response to multiple Freedom of Information Requests revealed that the agency had been aware of major deficiencies at the Boar’s Head production facility since October 2022, but had taken no action to suspend production or order a clean-up. These deficiences [sic] were described as posing an “imminent threat to product” in a Food Safety Assessment conducted in September/October 2022 What's somewhat disturbing is that there are politicians that think that it should work that way all the time. I don't remember the specific states, but remember reading that some state legislatures were upset that county health officials had been able to close in-person dining at restaurants during the height of the pandemic and had changed their laws so that county health officials could no longer close a restaurant for health code violations unless the health officials could demonstrate someone had actually been seriously sickened by the violation.