4 ms·
This article is weird. It flip flops between "bunkers are useless, you can hide in your basement" and "bunkers are useless, it won't protect you from a nuke". W
by gruez 2y ago
This article is weird. It flip flops between "bunkers are useless, you can hide in your basement" and "bunkers are useless, it won't protect you from a nuke". Which one is it? It doesn't even try to explain why bunkers "won't provide protection". The closest it gets is "I think the aftermath [of a nuclear exchange] will be uglier than many people think", but that instantly falls apart if the goal of the bunker isn't to stay 100% unscathed from a nuclear blast, but rather to increase the chances of survival.
- the_snooze 2y ago>The closest it gets is "I think the aftermath [of a nuclear exchange] will be uglier than many people think", but that instantly falls apart if the goal of the bunker isn't to stay 100% unscathed from a nuclear blast, but rather to increase the chances of survival. It's like fantasizing about surviving in a zombie apocalypse. It may seem cool and exciting, but the two most probable outcomes are either you'll be miserable from the neverending fight for survival, or you're a zombie yourself. In case of nuclear war, the best option is to start heading towards the likeliest targets and go in a relatively quick and painless way. There's nothing pleasant about a post-nuclear-war world.
- thmsths 2y agoSounds like they failed to perform a threat analysis. And that applies to both sides. The buyer thinks that the bunker will protect them no matter what, and the journalist takes the opposite and equally wrong position that the bunkers are virtually useless. As you correctly point out, they are useful in some situations, and for some people who can afford it they are worth the cost.
- perihelions 2y agoIt's the doublethink of someone who's trying to assert an argument for reasons under than actually understanding the technical question, or caring about the technical answer; and sees no problem in taking two different rhetorical paths to get that predetermined conclusion, even if they're mutually contradictory. (It's also like the legal concept of "pleading in the alternative" (?): "my client never borrowed that car; and it was already damaged when he received it; and he returned it in perfect condition". Permissible for defense lawyers—utterly discrediting for journalists).
- quitit 2y agoMy assumption is that they're hanging it all on this: >"Even if a nuclear exchange is perhaps more survivable than many people think, I think the aftermath will be uglier than many people think as well" / "The fundamental wrenching that it would do to our way of life would be profound." While I feel elaborating more would be helpful, it's probably not something that could be reasonably well covered in the scope of the article.