4 ms·

Very dismissive, and wrong objectively. You might want to try Claude, ask it to design a site/redesign part of a site or a component. Its really good. I designe

Very dismissive, and wrong objectively. You might want to try Claude, ask it to design a site/redesign part of a site or a component. Its really good. I designed this entire UI with Claude https://github.com/con-dog/context-aware-pattern-blocker https://github.com/con-dog/context-aware-pattern-blocker

dtagames 2y ago
It's great that it was able to assemble boilerplate components for an app like that, but that won't work for more complicated apps or ones that have to fit into an existing system.
- purple-leafy 2y ago
  I have a feeling with tailwind and a component library like shadcn or an equivalent, it’s very do-able for an LLM
  - thejazzman 2y ago
    Because it's copy and pasting Chad? That's not the same as seeing a novel design and implementing it. So much of this AI buzz is people just taking what they get and pretending it's exactly what they intended/envisoned, which they're just labeling whatever comes out Try asking for an SVG of a cow jumping over a moon. Then tell me, honestly, it's anything like what you imagined in your head
- bdangubic 2y ago
  used claude to fully re-design legacy system, 890 pages in total… you should spend more time working with various tools before dismissing like this. it is not just boilerplate components, it can do ridiculously complex UI logic (e.g. 27 tab page (don’t ask) with crazy validation dependencies) and ridiculously complex UI/UX
meiraleal 2y ago
Your generated design is far from good from an UI/UX perspective, which, as GP said, LLMs lack and can only achieve good results if you, the user of the LLM, know what you are doing (in this case, as a designer/UI/UX engineer).
sky2224 2y ago
How would claude handle generating a site that's as complex and detailed as a promotional page for an apple product (transitions and all)?
- pizza 2y ago
  I tried it out. Prompt: "generate a site that's as complex and detailed as a promotional page for an apple product (transitions and all)" result: https://claude.site/artifacts/ea99312f-5d7c-4b43-a4b9-6894784c785d https://claude.site/artifacts/ea99312f-5d7c-4b43-a4b9-689478...

dtagames 2y ago

It's great that it was able to assemble boilerplate components for an app like that, but that won't work for more complicated apps or ones that have to fit into an existing system.

purple-leafy 2y ago
I have a feeling with tailwind and a component library like shadcn or an equivalent, it’s very do-able for an LLM
- thejazzman 2y ago
  Because it's copy and pasting Chad? That's not the same as seeing a novel design and implementing it. So much of this AI buzz is people just taking what they get and pretending it's exactly what they intended/envisoned, which they're just labeling whatever comes out Try asking for an SVG of a cow jumping over a moon. Then tell me, honestly, it's anything like what you imagined in your head
bdangubic 2y ago
used claude to fully re-design legacy system, 890 pages in total… you should spend more time working with various tools before dismissing like this. it is not just boilerplate components, it can do ridiculously complex UI logic (e.g. 27 tab page (don’t ask) with crazy validation dependencies) and ridiculously complex UI/UX

meiraleal 2y ago

Your generated design is far from good from an UI/UX perspective, which, as GP said, LLMs lack and can only achieve good results if you, the user of the LLM, know what you are doing (in this case, as a designer/UI/UX engineer).

sky2224 2y ago

How would claude handle generating a site that's as complex and detailed as a promotional page for an apple product (transitions and all)?

pizza 2y ago
I tried it out. Prompt: "generate a site that's as complex and detailed as a promotional page for an apple product (transitions and all)" result: https://claude.site/artifacts/ea99312f-5d7c-4b43-a4b9-6894784c785d https://claude.site/artifacts/ea99312f-5d7c-4b43-a4b9-689478...