10 ms·
Did we look at the same chart? The characters in that last line are 3 or 4 pixels tall. I just did an experiment and 80% of guesses were wrong. There is just no
by ricardobeat 14y ago
Did we look at the same chart? The characters in that last line are 3 or 4 pixels tall. I just did an experiment and 80% of guesses were wrong. There is just not enough information, but this method can still decode them.
- rcthompson 14y agoUnfortunately, you don't know that the algorithm got the right answer for the letters on the bottom row. You'd have to try it on an image where you already knew the answers. Other comment threads note the there are lots of errors on that last line in the eye chart. Again, you can't recover more information than is in the image. When multiple characters look identical when scaled down, no algorithm can recover them reliably.
- ricardobeat 14y agoIt didn't, but it got pretty close (16 out of 22). Here's that one in better resolution: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/Eye-chart.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/Eye-chart...
- rcthompson 14y agoWell, with a 16/22 chance of getting a letter right, that gives a 15% chance of correctly reading a 6-letter license plate correctly. Of course that can be improved with more training, but I don't think it'll ever get high enough to make any dent in the conspiracy theories. Then again, maybe they'll all want to believe in the CSI-style zoom/enhance magic.
- ChrisClark 14y agoThe authors explained the chart, it only works because it looks across the whole chart for similar parts and recreates the smaller characters using the data it finds in the larger ones. So you would need a couple larger images of the licence plate too. Information cannot be created from nothing, the algorithm sees that the chart seems to be repeating a similar image over and over, so it guesses the best fit for those images on the bottom lines. They might even be completely wrong, for example, is it really a D and not an O?
- ricardobeat 14y agoYes. That's why the author mentions using other plate images from the time, having the same typeface, to seed the algorithm. He mentions that higher res photographs exist, which might yield a plate image of a similar resolution to that chart's smallest characters. He is not asking for magic, and it's obviously not "creating information from nothing". No one here is stupid. It's "matching low-density patterns to correlated high-density ones", which you already know if you read the article. Maybe there isn't enough data at all to do it - I don't have access to these images to know better, but that doesn't make the idea any less reasonable.