3 ms·
Other recent suggestions include: * Show that two irrationals can add up to a rational. * Find three whole numbers in arithmetic progression whose product is
by ColinWright 14y ago
Other recent suggestions include:
* Show that two irrationals can add up to a rational.
* Find three whole numbers in arithmetic progression whose product is a prime.
* Find a prime that is one less than a square. Now find another.
- dangoldin 14y agoI'm not sure what you mean by the second point. Three numbers whose product is prime? Did you mean sum? Edit: Nevermind - I just figured these out. Makes me feel a bit dumb now. That's what I get for not doing math for a few years. I really liked the last one - got me thinking.
- nhaehnle 14y ago> * Find three whole numbers in arithmetic progression whose product is a prime. I don't think there's an agreed upon definition of what a "whole number" is. Then again, if you're just looking for how someone reacts to such a question, I suppose it's fine, if a bit silly.
- ColinWright 14y agoInteresting - can you give me two possible plausible definitions of "whole number"?
- dangoldin 14y agoWikipedia has three possible definitions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whole_number http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whole_number All integers, integers >= 0, integers > 0
- tzs 14y agoAccording to both Wikipedia and Mathworld, "whole number" is sometimes used for: • The positive integers • The non-negative integers • The integers
- stephencanon 14y agoThe following usage is actually fairly common: Natural numbers: strictly positive integers Whole numbers: non-negative integers
- ColinWright 14y agoI'm intrigued to learn that some people have the convention that "-3" is not a whole number.
- stephencanon 14y agoI'm much more of an applied mathematician these days, but IIRC, the usage is especially prevalent in 19th century (and earlier) number theory, most often by authors who take the "natural numbers" to be {1,2,3,...} and therefore require a name for the set {0,1,2,3,...}. I have definitely come across the usage in more modern settings as well, however.
- tzs 14y agoFor the middle one, would you accept the arithmetic progression 1, 1, 1? I know that 1 is not considered to be a prime now, but it was considered to be a prime by most mathematicians up through the 19th century, and Lehmer included it in his lists of primes as late as 1956.
- kappaloris 14y ago1 1 2
- ColinWright 14y agoNot in arithmetic progression.
- ColinWright 14y agoIt's a defensible point of view, but I'd then ask for another.
- oo 14y ago-3,-1,1
- dllthomas 14y agos/whole number/integer/
- alexeismart 14y agoFor 1, suppose that x is irrational, that p is rational and q = p - x. Either q is rational or irrational. If q is rational then p - q is rational which would imply that x is rational. By contradiction, then p - x must be irrational. Therefore x + q = p, implying two irrational numbers can sum to a rational number. For 2, how about -3, -1 and 1. For 3, 3 is the only example. One less than a square is n ^ 2 - 1 = (n+1)(n-1). For n=2 the answer is 3 (3*1). For n > 2 the result is clearly factorable into two numbers > 1.
- masterzora 14y ago1. Why does every thread about FizzBuzz-esque problems always drive people to prove that they can solve the problem that is by definition minimum-competency. 2. The first is far more quickly solved by definition of the additive inverse, anyway.
- debacle 14y ago> For 3, 3 is the only example. Or 7, or 31, or 127.