2 ms·
That’s not how this technique works. There’s no magic here, just some algorithms. It doesn’t use time and space travel to reach back into the original scene an
by jacobolus 14y ago
That’s not how this technique works. There’s no magic here, just some algorithms.
It doesn’t use time and space travel to reach back into the original scene and pull data that wasn’t captured by the camera. Instead, it guesses at what the blown up image should look like based on an examination of other features already in the image, with some expectation that shapes and textures will be similar in different parts of the image and at different scales – will have a sort of fractal nature – and by aiming to make shapes with edges instead of fuzzy boundaries.
Using these algorithms can’t reveal the precise content of a license plate that was too small in the original image to see the letters of.
- alister 14y ago> license plate that was too small in the original image to see the letters of I did mention that better quality photos are available. And I did show that there are at least 2 photos of the same license plate -- there are probably more. In the photos printed in books, the license plate looks like the last couple lines of the Snellen eye chart in the original article -- i.e. it's quite blurry, but the super-resolution nethod was able to resolve it. > it guesses at what the blown up image should look like based on an examination of other features already in the image, with some expectation that shapes and textures will be similar in different parts of the image and at different scales It is true that there are no license plates at different scales in the same image. But are you quite certain that the technique cannot be applied across a range of photographs? That is, couldn't photos of license plates of the same type (and hence with exactly the same font) at different scales taken by the same photographic process on the same day in the same conditions have the same "fractal nature" that could be exploited to improve the resolution of the target photo? Let me put it another way: Suppose I cut up the Snellen eye chart into 6 equal pieces. Now I have 6 photos. Clearly, 5 of those photos can be used to improve the resolution of the 6th. Is there some principle at work here that says that for super-resolution to work, all data must come from a single original photo?
- jacobolus 14y agoIf you had several pictures of the same license plate, each of which was big enough to get meaningful information from but just barely too small to make out the letters when you blew it up with a regular bicubic interpolation + gaussian sharpening step, then you might be able to figure out more than you previously could. It seems quite unlikely to me, but go ahead and try it. If you look carefully, it’s actually possible to make meaningful guesses at the letters in the eye chart just as well in the bicubic version as in the “SR” version.
- ricardobeat 14y agoDid we look at the same chart? The characters in that last line are 3 or 4 pixels tall. I just did an experiment and 80% of guesses were wrong. There is just not enough information, but this method can still decode them.
- rcthompson 14y agoUnfortunately, you don't know that the algorithm got the right answer for the letters on the bottom row. You'd have to try it on an image where you already knew the answers. Other comment threads note the there are lots of errors on that last line in the eye chart. Again, you can't recover more information than is in the image. When multiple characters look identical when scaled down, no algorithm can recover them reliably.
- ricardobeat 14y agoIt didn't, but it got pretty close (16 out of 22). Here's that one in better resolution: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/Eye-chart.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/Eye-chart...
- rcthompson 14y agoWell, with a 16/22 chance of getting a letter right, that gives a 15% chance of correctly reading a 6-letter license plate correctly. Of course that can be improved with more training, but I don't think it'll ever get high enough to make any dent in the conspiracy theories. Then again, maybe they'll all want to believe in the CSI-style zoom/enhance magic.