4 ms·
Buying a TV in 2025? Expect lower prices, more ads, and an OS war
- pabs3 2y agoWonder what will happen after Vizio loses the GPL lawsuit against them. https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html
- Molitor5901 2y agoI purchased a television in 2019 and recently gave it away because I never used it. It was an LG and there were so many annoyances with it - slow software; branded buttons I could not change their functions; lack of transparency that it wasn't spying on me; advertisements and so much more, for more money.
- op00to 2y agoI have an LG OLED from ~2020 in my office which I've never connected to the internet. The picture quality is great. When I turn it on (using my video game console or Apple TV), it goes straight to that input. Other than first setting up the picture and audio and changing volume, I've never seen the interface nor have I seen ads. I have a much cheaper TCL TV with Roku built in, and I still have never connected it to the internet. It works similarly with an Apple TV. Having a large TV isn't a choice everyone makes, and that's ok. However, I don't think either TV is spying on me in any way that I care about.
- yapyap 2y agoI mean you may not think TVs are spying on you but it’s not something that just came out of nowhere. News stories nowadays have enshittified the knowledge on it, I tried to search for the Vault7 leak without the keyword Vault7 in it but by searching for “tv spying on you leak” paraphrased a bunch of different ways and all I got back from Google was the awful clickbait SEO optimized GARBAGE. But if the CIA was exposed for doing this shit 7 years ago back in 2017 when Smart TVs were a thing for sure but far from the only option compared to now where if you have a TV people automatically expect it to be a smart TV. https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/ https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/ PS: its so messed up what they did to Julian Assange
- op00to 2y agoIf the CIA is spying on my TV using zero day exploits, I have very big problems! I don't think it's worth TV manufacturer's time and effort to find ways to exfiltrate the BS I might say around my TV in ways that go beyond using a configured network connection, which I said is not something I have on any televisions under my control.
- ZeroCool2u 2y agoHopefully this will help someone else with a similar issue. I had this problem as well, so I bought the Google TV Streamer box and installed an alternative launcher called Dispatch. $10 for a lifetime license. No ads and the interface is Content, not app focused. Works pretty great and the dev is super responsive.
- code_for_monkey 2y agoI hate the branded buttons. My tv has ones for apps Ive never even heard of, but I cant just assign one to plex: the only streaming app I actually use
- izzydata 2y agoOn my Google Chromecast it was possible to download an app that lets me reassign the Netflix button to Plex. I also reassigned the Youtube button to Freetube.
- herbst 2y agoThat's the worst. My remote doesn't have numbers, not even arrows in a traditional sense. But it does have 4 branded buttons, 2 of which I never heard of.
- yapyap 2y ago“more ads” if youre buying a smart tv (vomit) yeah
- taeric 2y agoTo be fair, it still hasn't caught up to how many ads are on cable. Broadcast is probably still a rather gross place, in this regard.
- mschuster91 2y agoAt least broadcast doesn't microtarget their ads by snitching on what I watch or game.
- gorjusborg 2y agoTo be better than the worst is not to be good.
- taeric 2y agoI said to be fair. Not that this was a good. :( Which, to be fair, I should have flat said. I'm always terrified when I watch mainstream television while on a trip. The amount of advertising on normal television is mind boggling. Reminds me of places that don't have limits to billboards. So many billboards.
- 101008 2y agoThe future should be monitors with HDMI/USB input where you can plug whatever you want. Firesticks, Chromecasts, or your own open source alternative.
- code_for_monkey 2y agobut think of the products! Dont you want ads?? You havent thought of the corporations poor bottom line at all :(
- izzydata 2y agoI get the impression that TV manufactures already know that a large percentage of people are going to circumvent the built in OS with an external device so they put in very little effort into making it good.
- thejazzman 2y ago> large percentage I'd imagine it's dramatically less than even 1% of TV owners; we live in a tech bubble. My relatives aren't even interested in my going out of my way to do things like this for them. "Just let me watch TV" Normies don't care.
- hx8 2y agoThat was ~2007-2017. You are literally describing how TVs worked in the past. Still one of their core functionality.
- mdasen 2y agoIt should be the future, but it won't be. Roku's ARPU (average revenue per user) is around $40/year. If a company sells you a TV and there's a 50% chance you end up using the built-in smart platform and you keep the TV an average of 7 years, that could be an extra $140 for them. If the TV is selling for $300, that's an enormous amount of extra revenue. You might say that high-end TVs shouldn't come with ads, but the kind of person who buys a $1,000 TV is the most valuable kind of person to advertise to - rich, or at least willing to part with their money for high-ticket items. ARPU over 7 years might be $140 for all TVs, but the revenue from premium-TV buyers might be double or triple that. Would you be willing to pay an extra $140 for a TV? I'd guess yes - we're in this thread because we're more likely to. But most people probably wouldn't. And when it comes down to it, are we going to pay the extra $140 or just hope that we can disconnect it from WiFi and it's almost the same difference?
- FiniteLooper 2y agoI've still got a 55" Sony HDTV from around 2008. Zero network or smart features at all. Just a way to display images from another box. It's been so good and still is. I kind of of want to upgrade to something larger and in 4K, but every time I see an article like this I remember what is actually available in the market I feel like I'd rather just save my money and keep what I have that works how I like it
- nprateem 2y agoOr just use pihole to block all ads
- munk-a 2y agoYoutube is now embedding ads midstream - I think it's just a matter of time before other providers adopt similar approaches. When adblockers were tools exclusive to nerds it didn't make sense to build countermeasures - as advertising has grown more pervasive and obnoxious adblockers have gone mainstream and there is now an arms race that adblockers are currently on the losing side of.
- dbspin 2y agoEm... Adblockers still work perfectly? It's an annoyance to keep uBlock Origin updated, but it still blocks all ads on youtube. So it seems they're keeping up just fine.
- bookaway 2y agoWith adblockers disabled, I was seeing ads midstream ages ago. Ads that I don't see with an adblocker. Anecdotally, my subjective experience when adblockers are disabled seems to get exponentially worse whereas my adblocker experience seems to degrade at a much slower rate (e.g. manually skipping author recited ads on a podcast). Currently the TV is the weakest link, and people should be publishing layman's guides to pihole, or as others elsewhere have mentioned, refer them to a adblocking DNS redirect from an adblocker company. Midstream ads are especially obnoxious with music streams and I hope the majority's intolerance tips them over the edge.
- franczesko 2y ago"Today's TV selection has a serious dependency on advertisements and user tracking" Pretty much like every device we own. We need to go back to local-first software. I'd be happy to pay premium for a device, which is truly my, without big tech sniffing all my dataor deciding what can I do with it
- csense 2y agoAnyone know of good TV's? Either a "dumb" TV (HDMI and HDMI only), or the built-in electronics are easily rootable so you can replace the shovelware with Kodi (or stock Debian / Alpine / whatever).
- whalesalad 2y agoMy LG C2 OLED is great. I never connected to the internet. I have never seen an advertisement or pop-up or anything. For all intents and purposes, it is a dumb TV more like a computer monitor. I do not use any of the built-in applications, just literal HDMI1 (appletv) and HDMI3 (gaming pc). I adore it as a TV and would buy one again in a heartbeat. Not cheap though.
- bni 2y ago"Dumb" TVs don't really exist anymore, unless you get something from the very low end, but those have crap picture quality and build quality. Best option is LG OLED, never connect it to the network and set it to startup on HDMI1 always.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoPerhaps "TV" should be in quotes as well. In many cases, e.g., where the owner does not have good reception of digital free-to-air stations, the "TV" is effectively used as a monitor used to watch video downloaded to a internet-connected computer with an HDMI port ("set-top box", small form factor SBC, etc.). Despite cheap storage there is a culture of throwing away the downloaded video and replacing the word "download" with "stream". A monitor may also be combined with a computer in the same housing, but the fundamentals are the same: monitor, computer, video downloaded via internet. To me, "smart TVs" are just a way for someone else to keep a running list of everything the owner watches.
- someuser2345 2y agoI like the Sceptre TV's
- mrbigbob 2y agothe closest thing to a dumb TV are "commercial displays" that are designed for business signage, etc. sadly some of those now are even coming with OS's in them so if you are interested in going that route be careful what you purchase
- klodolph 2y agoRoku’s pending demise—it seemed apparent to me back when my Roku 4 was EOL’ed. Seemed like there was some kind of battle over streaming channels and some apps weren’t available. I understand the Roku 4 EOL was a little early due to some quirks of the device itself, since the Roku 3 is still supported today. The remote control was also poorly designed—it chewed through batteries like it was on a mission to prop up Duracell stock, and there was a noticeable delay between when you pressed a button and when the button took any action. The overall experience (declining app selection and poor experience with hardware) had me leaving Roku behind. My next TV will be a commercial digital signage display, unless somebody convinces me otherwise.
- hprotagonist 2y agoI will continue to not care, i think. Why would I want a TV when i can get a monitor and stuff a soundbar on the bottom, and an apple TV into HDMI1?
- erellsworth 2y agoThat may be a great solution for you. But if you want anything larger than 24 inches or so the cost is going to be astronomical compared to a TV.
- stabbles 2y agoSo, what is the recommendation for buying an ad-free TV in 2025?
- s1artibartfast 2y agodont
- Filligree 2y agoBuy a large monitor instead.
- everdrive 2y agoIt’s an interesting problem. At one point does someone just give up on buying TVs? I don’t necessarily mean “switch to a monitor + speakers” (which is a great alternative) — but rather I just mean at some point if the pain is great enough, why even have the TV? This is a technology category where people complain, but don’t actually change their behavior. Maybe in the current system there is no real market opening for dumb TVs; but if people actually cared, they’d just move away from watching TV altogether.
- onemoresoop 2y agoThe vast majority don’t understand what is going on nor do they have the knowhow to do the things they want to do that the said smart TVs claim to do for them. For now at least.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoNonsense. The majority could figure out how to install games or Microsoft Word. Why can't things be this simple? It's a failing of the tech companies and a $ issue.
- everdrive 2y agoBeing technically-savvy doesn’t have anything to do with not buying a TV. I think it’s the HN crowd which might make firewall rules or use pihole, or something else to successfully subvert a smart TV. But you don’t need any technical prowess to simply _not own one._ (you would, however, need to have at least some understanding that where is a privacy / datamining issues, so I would admit these two issues could be intermingled.)
- DrNosferatu 2y agoEnshitification just pushes people further to the grey market. I recently visited family and while there tried to watch YouTube without an adblocker, and the experience was unbearable.
- andrewla 2y agoMy TV is old and dumb and I love it. But the majority of my streaming is done through my Roku, and increasingly I am bombarded by advertising and attempts to sell Roku's own streaming service. Ironic because the reason that Roku exists rather than being part of Netflix is that Hastings didn't want the streaming to be tied to distribution. Looks like whatever they're doing isn't working as a strategy though if they're this close to being bought out. I personally wish that Roku would sell an ad-free no-self-streaming version at twice the price; three times the price. I'd snap it up in an instant and never look back. Do people have thoughts about the pros and cons of the alternatives? Amazon Fire TV is the only one that I've used extensively other than Roku and it is terrible. NVidia Shield? Plex? Google TV? Android TV? Apple TV? What do people like now?
- herbst 2y agoI bought a dumb TV to use with Kodi. The TV is so dumb tho I wouldn't do that again. Ex. Audio out exists only as 'headphone jack' output. Which is excluded from volume control. The OS, whatever that is, boots before it enables HDMI, adding nonsense waiting time. ...
- tassadarforaiur 2y agoAs long as it's possible, never connecting the TV to the home network, setting it to auto start to last HDMI used, and using a technician remote or HDMI arc control and mainly interacting with my apple tv / gaming console / audio receiver remote, has been able to suppress most of the TV OS garbage. Hopefully that continues to be an option.
- nerdjon 2y agoI have heard that there are apparently some TV's that won't let you use them without connecting them to the internet. But yeah, as long as thats possible than its fine. But if I am always put into their home system, or some other crap I don't want to interact with even if I am offline. Or I get regularly prompted to connect. It is going to be very frustrating and I am honestly not sure what I will do. Thankfully it wouldn't be too hard to get around the auto start on the same HDMI with a harmony remote or something with a hub to automatically switch it. Annoying, but fixable as long as it doesn't put up a box prompting you every time to connect. I have a Vizio tv from 2019, been looking at getting a new tv. and I am honestly starting to wonder if I have just been living in bliss that I can ignore its OS completely past my initial configuration.
- retrac 2y agoGiven the cost of an LTE modem these days I wouldn't be surprised if they start coming with integrated mobile service as a "feature" to ensure the ads and surveillance data always flow.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cruffle_duffle 2y agoWhy would they ever add that? Mass market means every penny added to the BOM counts. I mean I wouldn’t be surprised if some manufacturer added that but I imagine 99% of people who buy “low cost” TV’s walk right through the WiFi onboard screen and connect to the internet. The number of people who go out of their way to keep the TV off the network has to be incredibly low.
- mastercheif 2y agoI continue to be confused as to why there is such uproar over this. If you don't want ads on your TV... don't connect your TV to the internet. It will work exactly like a dumb TV.
- rglullis 2y agoWait until some genius PM decides that it is okay to open a "please connect your TV to the internet to update your device" while you are watching a movie... Or that they simply put a SIM card on the TV that phones home and fetches the ad inventory...
- jmuguy 2y agoI imagine one of the most important things to pay attention to on sites like rtings.com will be - what does the TV do if you don't connect it to the internet? The ads and the tracking are just the norm for people who can't be bothered to care, just like browsing the web is now. And those of us that can't stand it will continue to use external devices like the Apple TV (until Apple decides to start tracking or degrades that experience with ads, hopefully they won't).
- mdasen 2y agoBuying an Apple TV has been one of my best purchases. It's amazing having a box that just lets me get to my content rather than bombarding me with ads. It's also amazing how much better the box is. The UX is fast and responsive given that it has an A15 processor (same as an iPhone 14, but 5 core instead of 6 core). Single-core Geekbench scores are over 10x competitive players like the Google TV Streamer and multicore are around 7x. Given that a Google TV Streamer costs $100 and an Apple TV costs $130, you're getting a lot more value for your money with an Apple TV. Even an Nvidia Shield TV is 1/6th the speed in single-core and 1/5th the speed in multi-core. The Apple TV is a bit over-engineered, but most players are woefully underpowered and it leads to a terrible experience using them. Plus, it's just so nice buying a product where I'm not bombarded by ads and UX anti-patterns trying to confuse me so I part with my money. And I spend less money on the box too. $130 for an Apple TV is a lot less than what I've spent on Roku, Fire TV, Chromecast with Google TV, and Tivo Stream devices over the years - hoping one of them would work well.
- lytedev 2y agoNot an Apple TV, but I've had a similar experience with a cheap mini PC velcro'd to the back of my TV. A lot cheaper ($30), less plug'n'play, more software options. Pretty fantastic way to go!
- acureau 2y agoSame story here, I've got an old laptop and a wireless keyboard / trackpad combo. I haven't touched the TV interface since I set this up.
- andrewla 2y agoWhat do you use on the PC? Plex? Something else? I'm curious about this because it sounds appealing but I've found the software to be clunky and unreliable and often neglected by the streaming services.
- ubermonkey 2y agoHard same. An underrated feature of the ATV is that it will reach out and prompt you to use a keyboard on your phone when you need to enter values onscreen, which is WAY better than the character-by-character selection you get with lesser devices. We got our Samsung on a Black Friday sale in 2019. It's capable of being online, and we briefly experimented with using those features -- not the streaming apps, but the ability to have it show art or amusing graphics when idle. Ultimately I decided whatever info that was leaking wasn't worth it, and so I blanked the wifi settings, which had the effect of freezing the "suggested movies" list in amber at that moment. Its job is to show whatever external input we use -- AppleTV most of the time, but there's also a cable box/DVR, a Blu-Ray player, and an Xbox. The whole setup runs through an AV receiver, and the sound comes out of the surround system, so we really only need a dumb panel anyway.
- muststopmyths 2y agoBack in the day you could buy a commercial display Plasma, intended for trade show booths or display walls, as your home TV. Does that type of thing not exist more ?
- erellsworth 2y agoIt does. You can still get commercial displays. They just tend to cost a lot more than a consumer grade TV.
- muststopmyths 2y agointeresting. In case of plasma displays, the consumer ones used to be the more expensive by a wide margin.
- mschuster91 2y ago> "Today's TV selection has a serious dependency on advertisements and user tracking" Well, no surprise there, people vote with their wallet after all, and as a manufacturer you either go with the flow and subsidize your devices with ads and spyware, or you go and sink: TVs these days are commodities, unlike earlier times there is no reason for brand loyalty. Only chance if you want to escape the racket is pay the true price of the and get a Digital Signage line, bonus benefit, the components might actually be higher quality. Personal opinion: governments should go and ban selling goods of any kind below-cost. All that does is help create oligopolies where only the rich can participate because everyone else can't play the games of scale.
- kibwen 2y ago> governments should go and ban selling goods of any kind below-cost This is called "dumping" and is usually already illegal based on anti-competitive grounds, though mostly seems to only be enforced for international trade.
- mschuster91 2y agoIt's also really REALLY hard to prove dumping tactics, unfortunately, at least if there isn't a global commodity for the resource in question - it is easy to prove dumping/loss leads for stuff like grain, rice, coffee or whatnot, but a TV with its complex supply chains?
- kyriakos 2y agoSoftware that comes on the TV is always garbage or soon to be garbage because it won't be updated. An external player device will get you what you need being a Firestick, an NVidia Shield, RPi, Mini PC etc
- t0bia_s 2y agoJust buy a monitor or projector and plug in to home media server.
- pasttense01 2y agoExpect lower prices? Doesn't the author realize that they are all produced abroad--and Trump has promised massive tariffs.