4 ms·
There's only 7 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, total; winding it back a few hundred billion tonnes is not going to be physically possible un
by kragen 2y ago
There's only 7 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, total; winding it back a few hundred billion tonnes is not going to be physically possible unless you're talking about Venus. (Which is, admittedly, a pretty appealing prospect.) Here on Earth, the amount we need to remove is 0.02 hundred billion tonnes to get back to pre-industrial levels. That is, 2 billion tonnes. Of CO₂, not carbon.
There are a variety of different possibilities as to what to do with the extracted carbon. CO₂ is kind of an inconvenient form for making fuels from, so as long as they can cook oil and gas out of shale, people might just pump the carbon dioxide down wells and let it serpentinize some olivine, rather than reducing the carbon back out of it.
- philipkglass 2y agoTo one significant figure, the mass of CO2 in Earth's atmosphere is 3 trillion tonnes. Annual fossil fuel emissions of CO2 are about 37 billion tonnes: https://www.iea.org/reports/co2-emissions-in-2023/executive-summary https://www.iea.org/reports/co2-emissions-in-2023/executive-...
- kragen 2y agoHmm, I'll have to figure out how I got that so wrong. That would explain some things that were bothering me about the Portland cement stats I posted yesterday. Thanks for the heads up!
- defrost 2y agoNo drama from my PoV - it's easy to get magnitudes etc. wrong and these are large numbers. I haven't checked against the GeoPhys journals (I should, but ...), FWiW wikipedia has it that: In October 2023 the average level of CO2 in Earth's atmosphere, adjusted for seasonal variation, was 422.17 parts per million by volume (ppm). Each part per million of CO2 in the atmosphere represents approximately 2.13 gigatonnes of carbon, or 7.82 gigatonnes of CO2. where gigatonne == (US) billion tonne ~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_atmosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_at... That's total, not just the excess portion added in by human activity and sourced from the bowels of the earth via mining for concentrated old sunlight energy. Still, despite the fractional ppm composition that's a full atmospheric total of 3,301 billion tonne. Here in W.Australia we move approx one billion tonne of iron ore from the Pilbara to (mostly) China per year. That takes some effort and energy.
- kragen 2y agoIt sure looks like I was somehow using the 7.82 gigatonne number as the total, rather than multiplying it by the necessary 422. A simple calculation in units(1) shows that your figure is the right order of magnitude: You have: 400ppm 4pi earthradius**2 atm / gravity You want: trillion tonnes * 2.1080571 / 0.47437046 That's a bit low because the 422 ppm number is by volume, not weight, but that is relatively easy to correct with the molecular masses, assuming ideal gas behavior: You have: 422ppm (carbon + 2 oxygen) 4pi earthradius**2 atm / gravity (21% 2 oxygen + 79% 2 nitrogen) You want: trillion tonnes * 3.3925982 / 0.29475934 And that's within 3% of the number you give from Wikipedia.