10 ms·
While that is nice to know, it still smells of Raketeering to me. "that is some nice software you have there, would be a shame if users thought it was dangerou
by tomjen3 14y ago
While that is nice to know, it still smells of Raketeering to me.
"that is some nice software you have there, would be a shame if users thought it was dangerous"
"pay a little money to one of these approved companies and that warning will go away"
If MS was serious about this only being for security they could issue the certificates for free and prove me wrong.
On the other hand, why is it that about 20% of users click past BOTH of these EXTREEMLY scary warnings? Don't they read them at all?
- SomeCallMeTim 14y ago>If MS was serious about this only being for security they could issue the certificates for free and prove me wrong. Make it too easy, and the scamware software will just get a free cert and sign apps. It takes some amount of effort, possibly by a human, to approve you to receive a cert. Even the "free" certs I've applied for have taken time and human interaction on the side of the registrar, and I'm certain those certs are offered as loss-leaders for their other products.
- hobin 14y agoI'm unfamiliar with many of these certificates, but is there any reason such 'scamware' woudln't be able to get one even though it costs money? Because, if they still can, they the whole certification business definitely seems like a big scam to me.
- dennisgorelik 14y agoWhen you pay money - you are leaving money trace which is likely to bite you if your product hurts people.
- yuhong 14y agoYea, the SmartScreen filter is based on the reputation of the publisher, and the certificate is used to identify the publisher for this purpose.
- lesterbuck 14y agoThe certificate authority should revoke their signing certificate if their binary is found to contain malware, returning them to the big warning state.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoApple gives out free developer id certificates. There's no reason Microsoft couldn't do the same.
- X-Istence 14y agoWhere does Apple give out free developer id certificates? Last I saw I had to purchase the $99 developer program ... https://developer.apple.com/resources/developer-id/ https://developer.apple.com/resources/developer-id/
- DeepDuh 14y ago"Buy this cd boxset and you will get this wonderful christmas album FOR FREE!"
- Turing_Machine 14y agoOkay, "free" was poor phrasing. I should have said "no extra charge". Compare this to the situation described in the original article, where the developer had to buy a separate $59 certificate from a third party, on top of what Microsoft charges you for Visual Studio (which looks to be $499 for the cheapest non-evaluation version).
- ryanbrunner 14y agoExpress isn't an evaluation version. Also, it's trivially easy to get setup with BizSpark if you're a small startup and get free copies of Visual Studio.
- Turing_Machine 14y agohttp://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/05/no-cost-desktop-software-development-is-dead-on-windows-8/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/05/no-cos... No mobile apps, no conventional desktop apps, no command line apps... looks pretty "evaluaty" to me. Also: "private developers will have to pay $49 a year, corporations $99 a year." So, on the one hand we have (from Apple): Xcode (free or $5.00, depending on what kind of mood Apple is in that week) Developer program with store access: $99/year Code-sigining certificate: included. From Microsoft we have: Non-crippled Visual Studio: $499 Developer program with store access: $49-$99/year Code-signing certificates: must be purchased separately from a third party. What a bargain!
- Karunamon 14y ago>it still smells of Raketeering to me. Congratulations - you have been enlightened to the state of PKI as it stands today. (I.e. a complete fucking scam).
- praxulus 14y agoI'm afraid I haven't been enlightened. How else can the PKI be structured while providing the same amount of security? Is public/private key cryptography itself fundamentally flawed? What's the alternative?
- Karunamon 14y agoMost people care less about assurance and more about encryption. I.e., unless you're subject to a MITM DNS attack, you're a lot less likely to be directed at the wrong paypal.com than you are to say, have your password sniffed off the wire, or by a keylogger on the local machine. And that identity assurance is where most of the scam comes in. Encrypting communication securely is dead simple (from an implementation standpoint - pick a cipher and go), making sure server X actually represents who they say they do, that's a whole different can of worms.
- harshreality 14y agoSome combination of distributed notaries, warning for unusual certificate conditions (e.g. certs changing when they have lots of time until expiration -- Dear Google, please stop doing that), and other ideas. Convergence http://convergence.io/ http://convergence.io/ (notary) Perspectives http://perspectives-project.org/ http://perspectives-project.org/ (notary) CertPatrol http://patrol.psyced.org/ http://patrol.psyced.org/ (cert checking) TACK http://tack.io/ http://tack.io/ (only one cert per organizational group would need signing or notarizing)
- barista 14y ago>> it still smells of Raketeering to me Racketeering indeed! I am sure that was the goal of the SmartScreen filter in IE. Cert vendors and MS must have colluded to add this feature so that developers of all binaries are forced to buy certs. Right?
- CapitalistCartr 14y agoAs the saying goes, "The road to Hell is paved with good intentions." Welcome to the 'law' of unintended consequences. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences
- tomjen3 14y agoIf not, why not include the option of a free cert for each windows/compiler download? That way even those who ship free software would sign it and thereby make windows safer. But of course MS isn't interested in that when they can get paid for it.
- ryanbrunner 14y agoI'm sure a large part of the reason Microsoft wouldn't offer it for free is that, at the time, any effort on Microsoft's part to enter a new market off the back of an existing market would be scrutinized pretty heavily by the DOJ. They couldn't even add virus scanning functionality to Windows because of anti-trust concerns.
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoMany users have figured out that if they click the OK button (or maybe the Cancel button), the dialog goes away. In this case, they know that they get what they want (downloaded file) if they hit the right buttons; they've probably hit exactly this before, on innocuous programs, and don't trust the warning messages. Or we might just have a bunch of reasonably-savvy users that have realized that lack of a signature is not the same as untrustworthy software.