3 ms·
In my experience, one of the biggest factors driving people to have the author's experience is... backwards compatibility. The old ways of doing things have ex
by zahlman 2y ago
In my experience, one of the biggest factors driving people to have the author's experience is... backwards compatibility.
The old ways of doing things have existed for much longer than the new ways, and become well established. Everyone just accepts the idea of copying Pip into every new virtual environment, even though it's a) totally unnecessary (even before the `--python` option was introduced two years ago, you could sort of get by with options like `--target` and `--python-version` and `--prefix` and `--platform` and `--abi`) and b) utterly insane (slow, wasteful, makes it more confusing when your PATH gets messed up, leads to misconceptions...). And that's before considering the things people try to do that aren't officially blessed use cases - like putting `sudo` and `--break-system-packages` on the same command line without a second thought, or putting code in `setup.py` that actually tries to copy the Python files to specific locations for the user, or trying to run Pip explicitly via its non-existent "API" by calling undocumented stuff instead of just specifying dependencies (including "extras" lists) properly. (The Pip documentation explicitly recommends invoking Pip via `subprocess` instead; but you're still probably doing something wrong if this isn't part of your own custom alternative to Poetry etc., and it won't help you if Pip isn't available in the environment - which it doesn't have to be, except to support that kind of insane use case).
Another part is that people just don't want to learn. Yes, you get a 'Giant full page warning saying “use a venv you idiot”'. Yes, the distro gets to customize that warning and tell you exactly what to do. Users will still give over a million hits to the corresponding Stack Overflow question (https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75608323 https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75608323), which will collect dozens of terrible answers, many of them suggesting complete circumvention of the package-management lock. It was over a year before anything significant was done about the top answer there (disclosure: I contributed quite a bit after that point; I have a personal policy of not writing new answers for Stack Overflow, but having a proper answer at the top of this question was far too important for me to ignore), which only happened because the matter was brought to the attention of the Python Discourse forum community (https://discuss.python.org/t/_/56900 https://discuss.python.org/t/_/56900).