4 ms·
There is no legitimate justification to infringe on a contract between a willing buyer and a willing seller Devils advocate: are food standards also a terrible
by untog 14y ago
There is no legitimate justification to infringe on a contract between a willing buyer and a willing seller
Devils advocate: are food standards also a terrible imposition? The government insists on coming around to all the restaurants in the city and inspecting them to make sure that no-one will be poisoned or killed by the food they eat. How dare they stand in between a willing buyer and seller. Right? Right?
Food standards, restaurant inspections, building codes, health and safety codes... the list goes on. Are they all illegitimate attempts to stand between a willing buyer and seller?
- mseebach 14y agoWhile not always perfectly implemented, the government acts as representatives of the buyers in that transaction.
- cgmorton 14y agoIf my friend grows tomatoes in her back yard, should I be prohibited and fined for eating one without it first being inspected? Inspections are there because large institutions don't always take the care they should, and as a consumer I sure as hell want -somebody- to look into it. If it weren't a government institution then I'd expect some sort of company to do it, and any restaurant that hadn't gotten inspected I would avoid. On the other hand I -don't- worry when I use Air-BnB, because it has reviews that signify quality, and because there's not much that can go wrong with sleeping on a couch.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoIt has little to do with the reasons for regulating food, and everything to do with the means. In order to keep me from buying soda, you have to forcibly come between the peaceful and free association of me and another person. You're not going to convince me that I would still buy raw milk, or that pasteurized milk would be unavailable, in the absence of FDA regulation.
- untog 14y agoHow would you know if you were buying raw or pasteurized milk if there were no food labelling regulations obligating people to label it accordingly?
- dreamdu5t 14y agoJust like I do now. I look for milk labeled "pasteurized" and make sure it's from a trusted vendor/brand or has a trusted certification. There's a competitive advantage to labeling food, and there's no stopping companies from labeling food in the absence of food labeling regulations. The most trusted organic certification is from a for-profit certification company, Quality Assurance International. McDonald's published nutrition information before it was required by any law. Intentionally incorrect labeling is already covered by fraud and tort law.