5 ms·
Pompeii experts back Pliny's account of Mount Vesuvius eruption date
- jmyeet 2y agoFun fact: we know the Vesuvius eruption, whatever the date, was on a Wednesday. How? Because we found a bread called Panis Quadratus that was only baked on Wednesdays [1]. Pompeii (and Herculaneum) are endlessly fascinating and about a third of Pompeii remains underground and hasn't been examinted yet. [1]: https://www.visitnaples.eu/en/neapolitanity/flavours-of-naples/the-2000-year-old-bread-found-at-pompeii-excavations https://www.visitnaples.eu/en/neapolitanity/flavours-of-napl...
- zachrip 2y agoWhat if it was from the day prior?
- sourpunchicle 2y agothen it'd be stale
- db48x 2y agoIt _was_ stale when they found it.
- KZerda 2y agoThe bread was found in the oven of one of the bakeries[1]. It wouldn't be in the oven if the bread was from the day before. [1] https://www.bbc.com/travel/article/20230406-arculata-the-bread-that-survived-pompeii https://www.bbc.com/travel/article/20230406-arculata-the-bre...
- davidw 2y agoNow I'm envisioning a discount rack like my local Albertson's has, in Pompeii. "Panis Quadratis - L % off!"
- ithkuil 2y agoI'm confused. Rome didn't have a 7 day week until Constantine introduced it in 321 CE Rome used an 8 day cycle called "nundinal cycle". (And yes the name of the 8 day cycle contains the root of the number 9, novem, because Romans of course also invented off-by-one errors) Days were named with letters from A to H. What does it mean that the Panis Quadratus was baked on a Wednesday? That sparked my curiosity and I tried to find more accounts of this alleged ritual of baking specific kinds of breads on specific days of the week but I couldn't find much. It seems that somebody wrote a piece about panem quadratus on Wednesday and a few other types of breads and that's got copy-pasted around including some touristic website from Naples. I call bullshit, but I may be wrong. Does anybody know more about it?
- kopirgan 2y agoThe article doesn't explain the charcoal inscription discrepancy?
- twiss 2y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/kristinakillgrove/2018/10/16/new-pompeii-graffiti-may-rewrite-history-in-a-major-way/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kristinakillgrove/2018/10/16/ne... says: > it is not known whether the Oct 17 graffito referred to that day, or a day in the past or the future The last option would explain it, potentially.
- adastra22 2y agoI'm not a Pompeii expert, but from what I understand Pliny the Younger was there, witnessed the eruption first-hand, and barely survived to tell the tale. Which he did, in a book that has survived to the present day. He gave the date of 24 August, year 79. Why was this ever in doubt?
- ch4s3 2y agoConfirming the date doesn’t mean that it was in doubt, it’s just new evidence that strengthens his account.
- jeremyjh 2y agoYou are right, its the content of TFA that tells us it was in doubt.
- defrost 2y agoHis uncle, Pliny the Elder, was closer and died in Stabiae, a town close to Pompeii that was partially covered in ash, while attempting to rescue a friend. Pliny the Younger was across the Bay of Naples and witnessed the eruption from a distance. Of interest, the two letters written by Pliny the Younger: https://igppweb.ucsd.edu/~gabi/sio15/lectures/volcanoes/pliny.html https://igppweb.ucsd.edu/~gabi/sio15/lectures/volcanoes/plin... ( hosted at the Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics as being the first recorded witnessing of a volcanic eruption ) The date is likely to be accurate as Pliny the Elder's will formerly adopted Pliny the Younger as a "son" and left him a considerable fortune. The major eruption occurred in cycles over two days, subsequent ash falls that continued to kill may have persisted a week. It's possible that 50 years on there may be some inaccuracy in the account wrt dates as Pliny the Younger may have referenced documents that dated when his uncles estate was settled rather than the date of his death.
- adastra22 2y agoHe saw it with his own eyes, making him a primary source. I would say that counts as "being there." As you say, this is a life-transforming event for Pliney the Younger. For him to get the date off by an entire season is quite a stretch.
- mercurialuser 2y agoOn a recent tv reconstruction by an italian TV show about historically events ("una giornata particolare") it seems that the archeologists are finding remains of food typical of the autumn