4 ms·
the only real limit is until you start interfering with other people to the point they notice and complain. it's not like the FCC has vans roving the streets lo
by dylan604 2y ago
the only real limit is until you start interfering with other people to the point they notice and complain. it's not like the FCC has vans roving the streets looking for unlicensed TV usage like the BBC but for wifi.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoThere's a LOT of testing done, before you can sell a device, including TX power measurement. And yes, they have vans roving the streets looking for illegal transmissions.
- hnuser123456 2y agoTo be fair, there are a lot of people in the FPV drone community using 600mW+ 5ghz transmitters for analog video without HAM licenses, and I don't think I've ever heard of anyone getting in trouble for it. But that's typically in unpopulated areas.
- withinboredom 2y agoAlso, they are gone before anyone can triangulate them.
- BubbleRings 2y agoHa. My friend and I had the FCC van roving our neighborhood looking for us once, back in the late 70s. A guy with a CB base station dropped a dime on us, cause we were playing with our 0.1 watt walkie talkies near his house. The guy that sold us the handhelds said “what channel crystal do you want, how about 9?” and we said sure; we didn’t know that 9 is the emergency CB channel and the law prevents its use for, for example, playing hide and seek as a 13 year old.
- dylan604 2y agoOf all of those hypothetical "if you could go back in time" situations, I'd want to go back and rat that guy out for selling kids that crystal. Just the other day in another thread there was the conversation about mischievous people doing things, and that pretty much sounds like what that guy was doing. He got the best of both worlds knowing he was going to cause some chaos but none of the repercussions of it.
- pmontra 2y agoI bet he had had that crystal on the shelf for a long time and he kept trying to sell it.
- gonzo 2y ago47 CFR 95.931(a)(2):"CBRS Channel 9 may be used only for emergency communications or traveler assistance. It must not be used for any other purpose." Since the goal of hide and seek is to get home (before found) I’d call that traveler assistance. <grin>
- dylan604 2y ago> And yes, they have vans roving the streets looking for illegal transmissions. Only and when they receive complaints. Then they have to decide if it is serious enough to care. This is a far cry different than active BBC patrols. I clearly stated until people notice and complain. It's like these words were totally ignored.
- rtkwe 2y agoNot for all devices and they're not even particularly good at catching sellers who should provide testing data and register but don't.
- connicpu 2y agoThey aren't sniffing around residential homes unless they have a reason to suspect someone is interfering with someone else's licensed spectrum, but if you're _selling_ a device that doesn't comply with the legal limits they will see you in court.
- topspin 2y agoThe FCC does hunt down illegal AM/FM broadcast transmitters in residences. They publish several forfeiture orders every month for pirate radio stations (often in residences,) whether their interfering or not. Hunting these is lucrative business given the PIRATE Act (S.1228) and its hefty fines. I've never seen this happen for a WiFi band operator, so yeah, they're aren't looking. They certainly could though: someone is using all those grey market boosters. Some of those have enough power to show up for many miles, and triangulating them is quite easy. They do go after cell jammers. One example from 2016 was a guy in Florida using one in his car during his daily commute. People complained their signals failed at about the same time every day and the FCC pursued it and caught him. $48K fine.
- RF_Savage 2y agoEnforcement action is likely driven by complaints from other users. Both FM broadcast and telcos pay for their exclusive slices, so enforcement happens quicker.
- topspin 2y ago> Enforcement action is likely driven by That's speculation. I know what is written in the notices and orders. The orders do not cite either complaints or determinations about interference. The notices do. Some of these document complaints with the formula: "in response to complaints." Others do not, such as this[1]. [1] https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-24-09A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-24-09A1.pdf My inference is that when actual complaints exist they are documented, for evidentiary reasons. Thus, when the existence of complaints is omitted, no such complaints exist.
- heavyset_go 2y agoDon't underestimate the determination of hams to find people that aren't playing by the rules on the spectrum.
- dylan604 2y agoagain, until someone notices and complains. i don't know why we're being argumentative here
- heavyset_go 2y agoYou're interpreting what I meant to be a joke as argumentative.
- dylan604 2y agoread the room of the rest of the comments. also, i failed to see you used the funny font
- jameshart 2y agoThis is a sad approach to legal compliance. One reason regulations like this exist is to save people the burden of having to worry that some asshole will suddenly start transmitting in a way that interferes with you and you’ll have to go to the trouble of complaining. You can proceed on the general assumption that other people will be acting within the agreed limits. It’s a very selfish attitude to take to say ‘Ah, I’ll just crank up the gain til someone complains’ rather than ‘I guess I’ll stick within the guidance so I don’t inconvenience anyone’.
- fargle 2y agoi mean, to some people the FCC is the overreach that represents "a sad approach to compliance": > some asshole will suddenly start transmitting in a way that interferes with you remember LightSquared/Ligado Networks? assholes, but with $$$ tho. still a thing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23103290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23103290 https://www.gps.gov/spectrum/ligado/ https://www.gps.gov/spectrum/ligado/
- dylan604 2y agoThis site is called Hacker News. It's a place where people like to tinker, poke, prod, probe things to see what it is they can do with it. It's pretty fundamental to take something and see if you can make it go to 11. There are ramifications to some of these "hacks". Knowing that and how to avoid getting caught is part of the DNA of the hacking ethos. Sometimes, your hack is harmless. Sometimes, it is slightly annoying. Sometimes, it is flat out illegal. Knowing exactly (or trying to find out) how far you can bend without breaking is part of the culture. Once again, I say that you can push your TX higher than "accepted" and for the most part get away with it. If you push it higher to have negative consequences on other people (especially those other hackers that feel slighted) will seek to fix the glitch. I'm really confused on how this original comment is so lost on here.
- karteum 2y ago> the only real limit is until you start interfering with other people to the point they notice and complain. it's not like the FCC has vans roving the streets looking for unlicensed TV usage like the BBC but for wifi In the area of radio, you must be extremely careful with this mindset. Keep in mind that interference may affect important / safety-critical infrastructure (and you may not even realize). For example, I am frequency facing issues from wifi (with deactivated or nonfunctional DFS) towards a weather radar in the same band (which indeed is the primary user, and weather forecasts are critical to aeronautical and maritime safety ! This is a nightmare to troubleshoot). If you want to tinker with radio, I would suggest to pass your HAM radio license (which will give you the minimum background with regards to radio, propagation, regulations, etc.). Because an increasing number of people do not care anymore about any regulations, I see many administrations worldwide are increasingly pushing for locked firmwares and bootloaders (i.e. no more openwrt), more import control, etc. If you want to still be able to tinker with hardware and radio in the future, you should always ensure peaceful coexistence with others i.e. know what you are doing and work within the boundaries of regulations (be it txpower, duty-cycle, listen-before-talk, etc. Those limits are there for a good reason !).
- Aurornis 2y agoOthers have already covered the legal problems with this. I’ll add that going over 1W or even less with typical WiFi gear can introduce enough distortion to offset the power gains. WiFi hardware is cost optimized. It’s likely that the PA chips in your radio are going to distort if pushed past the legal limits. Many radios distort heavily past 100mW. Its common for people to turn the power setting all the way up thinking they’re getting the best performance, but best performance might occur at a lower setting.
- dylan604 2y agoSomeone trained/learned/schooled in this stuff might know that. But for a curious hacker getting at the internals of how something works, the first instinct is to turn it up. That's their learning path. It's natural curiosity. More must be better. Louder must be better. The point is to stop scaremongering about letting people turn up the TX. It's just a damn WiFi radio. They aren't going to be blocking their neighbor from listening to their favorite ClearChannel session of commercials. At most their neighbor might get a bit of interference. But if you're running on the same channel as your neighbor, you're already asking for trouble. Nobody's going to emergency, nobody's going to jail. We're not talking about firing up an 100kW flame thrower of a radio signal here. Let's just everyone keep their knickers on and realize the context of what we're discussing
- karteum 2y ago> But for a curious hacker getting at the internals of how something works, the first instinct is to turn it up. That's their learning path. It's natural curiosity. More must be better. Louder must be better. If you increase the TXpower way beyond the P1dB of your PA, you will introduce distorsion and therefore harmonics beyond your operating band (i.e. you can end up disturbing RF services other than wi-fi, possibly safety-critical services). https://www.everythingrf.com/community/what-is-p1db https://www.everythingrf.com/community/what-is-p1db => Don't do that !
- mordae 2y agoHarmonics. What safety critical stuff is at 4.8 GHz, 7.2 GHz, ...?