3 ms·
Crypto Doesn't Deserve a Tax Exemption
- bnchrch 2y agoLike most modern regulation problems, we suffer from two things. 1. We are trying to fit new concepts to old systems 2. We lack sufficient clear and agreed upon terminology and definitions. You could see this in the privacy argument for files when they are uploaded to the cloud and if they were free to access by law enforcement. You can see this now in the blanket statement of "crypto" that fails to acknowledge that it contains projects that act like equities, others like currency, and some like both.
- loeg 2y ago> blanket statement of "crypto" that fails to acknowledge that it contains projects that act like equities, others like currency, and some like both. It's kind of an inverse relationship, isn't it? The ones with the most capital gains are the least currency-like; anything that behaves like a currency (perhaps USDC or USDT) has no appreciable capital gains to tax anyway.
- Lerc 2y agoBitcoin has interacting forces that work in opposite directions. The increase in value makes it provide income as capital gains, but reduces its ability to be a currency. Reduced ability as a currency inhibits its value, reducing it's ability to provide income as capital gains. It's hard to assess what this would mean over time when you already know the history of the price biasing your viewpoint. Especially when you have to modulate that value by the effects of media coverage and public opinion contributing to a boom/bust cycle. I could see how it could be consistent with the price history with stepped increases in value as its long term potential as a currency is reassessed as being more likely, each step triggers an oscillation as the opposing forces react to the change in value and change in stability respectively. I think spread latency (not everyone reacts to the forces at the same rate) would have a dampening effect causing things to flatten out over time. Worst case scenario would be if the competing forces cause an ever increasing oscillation. I think that should mean that the end state for Bitcoin should be relatively stable, but at a value that we just don't yet know $0, $100, $1,000,000 could all happen. If it turns out to be $1,000,000, I'm completely ok with people paying tax on the increase in value if they bought at $10. On the other hand if the price remains stable around there, then people who used it as a currency would not generate much taxation income, but cause a considerable amount of paperwork to keep track of everything. Perhaps in that instance A percentage capital gain threshold would be in order. Perhaps something like, if the gain over a period is more than inflation_rate*1.1 capital gains tax kicks in.
- ozim 2y agoIANAL but everything that is supposed to be “new concept” is covered by existing laws. People mostly are not aware of what is there really written in law and second and maybe more important don’t want to know because if they would apply existing law they would not earn as much. Ignoring laws just like Uber or Airbnb doesn’t make law not applicable or a new concept. Driving people around for money was regulated, the same with renting apartments. The same with cryptocurrency stuff and coin offerings - something being a meme coin doesn’t magically make law not applicable if dozens of people buy it with hope for its value increasing and people selling it making funny pictures about going to “the moon” instead of promising future returns.
- loeg 2y agohttps://archive.is/ae1eh https://archive.is/ae1eh
- Lerc 2y agoI'm quite surprised that opinion columns end up behind a paywall. If you consider from the principle of supply and demand, it feels like we should be being paid to read these things. The limited resource is not opinions, but the time it takes to read them.
- ObscureMind 2y agoThe American Revolution was partly sparked by the "Tea Act" of 1773, which imposed taxes on tea without colonial representation. The colonists saw this as unjust. Fast forward to today, and many people seem to accept high taxes on goods and services as necessary, while viewing tax exemptions as undeserved or privileged. Perhaps everything deserves a tax exemption, especially cryptocurrency, which operates independently of government control and doesn’t rely on state structures to function.
- Fezzik 2y agoWhich courts hear disputes regarding crytpo currencies? Which law enforcement officers investigate crimes related to crypto currencies? Which grids power mining? You live in a very dark bubble if you think crypto currencies are somehow operating outside of all the benefits of a society.
- ObscureMind 2y agoIf every government worldwide were to forget about or ban cryptocurrencies entirely, they would still persist. Governments, in this case, offer nothing essential to the functioning of cryptocurrencies. Cryptos are essentially just digital numbers transferred across the internet, their existence sustained purely by individuals investing their time, resources, and trust. Their value and continued operation are independent of government control, investment, infrastructure, or approval.
- cadamsau 2y agoWhile I agree with what you’re saying in the first order, what would actually happen is pretty predictable - an even more extreme version of what we’re seeing with scams, lost wallets, pump & dump schemes, fake ICOs and people taking advantage of each other with impunity. Cryptos are simple but cryptoCURRENCY - where the rubber hits the road and the numbers on the internet become useful - is anything but.
- binarycrusader 2y agocryptocurrency, which operates independently of government control and doesn’t rely on state structures to function. It magically manifests itself through the ether? It doesn’t rely on profligate amounts of cheap electricity and the infrastructure required to support data centers? It doesn’t rely on governments that provide a legal and financial system that supports exchange into actual monetary value that the real world requires to operate? Claiming cryptocurrency doesn’t rely on state structure completely ignores the existing state structures that are required to enable the complex scheme that’s needed to enable its use. As they say, “we live in a society.”
- PopAlongKid 2y ago>If you “sell” your money, say to buy a car, the government does not tax you on that transaction, claiming that you earned a “capital gain” on your money. So why should you be taxed on the capital gains if you used crypto to buy a car? This is complete nonsense. You aren't taxed on buying something, you are taxed on realizing the gains you have achieved. If you traded some stocks to someone to buy their car, you would similarly be taxed on the portion of the sale price that was attributed to realized gains.
- loeg 2y agoYeah. More to the point, you're taxed on capital gains in dollar terms. Cash is 1:1 with dollars -- it will always have exactly zero in capital gains. So in some sense you are taxed on capital gains of cash you use to buy things -- it's just exactly $0.
- cesarb 2y ago> The best argument in favor of the incoming administration’s proposal is simply that crypto is a different kind of asset, not money itself but like money in some ways. If you “sell” your money, say to buy a car, the government does not tax you on that transaction, claiming that you earned a “capital gain” on your money. So why should you be taxed on the capital gains if you used crypto to buy a car? What if you paid for the car in pesos, instead of dollars, would you have a capital gains tax (honest question, I don't know how it works in the USA)? Nobody would say pesos aren't money. (For the special case of dollars, it makes sense that there's no "capital gain" to tax: since the "capital gain" is measured in dollars, the gain or loss on your dollars is always zero.)
- chemeng 2y agoTypically payments in the foreign currency are pegged to exchange rates, in which case you’re still paying the same amount of “value” whether in pesos or dollars. Regardless you’d be subject to Section 988 and could potentially owe capital gains (or ordinary income) tax if you had a large enough gain from buying, holding and then exchanging the foreign currency. The US code treats all non-USD currency as property, so you can (mostly) think of it as any other transaction with an exchange between assets. There are some nuances and exceptions of course.
- Kirby64 2y agoCurrency arbitrage would be taxed as normal income. The more specific example being buying pesos, then reselling pesos for US dollars at a gain. There are exclusions for currency conversion below a threshold for personl expenses such as travel, per Section 988 in the US: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/section-988.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/section-988.asp Since the only 'allowed' currency is US dollars here, any exchange to a non-US-dollar 'currency' (pesos, bitcoin, whatever) then using that to buy/sell things would implicitly trigger either a capital gains or a regular income event upon conversion to another form of value. It's no different than buying and selling art, or any goods. If I constructed all of business around bartering using rice... technically I would owe taxes on all those transactions.
- 2y ago
- spprashant 2y agoIt's been over a decade that I have seen crypto in the mainstream space, and I am yet to see any decent adoption for BTC - either online or in the physical world. El Salvador went as far as to mandate everyone to accept BTC as payments, but the public has mostly ignored. Now they are rolling back the mandates. The "currency" isn't backed by any institution, takes forever to send/receive tokens, has absurd transaction fees, cherry on top, is terrible for the environment. Did we really need an alternative for gold that bad?
- lern_too_spel 2y agoSpeculators gonna speculate. Pump and dumpers gonna pump and dump. Rubes gonna rube. That's the same as any other underregulated commodities market. Cryptocurrency lets ransomware authors easily profit off of those people as well. That's the innovation.
- devops99 2y agoThey want to tax you on the inflation-driven devaluation of their own shitcoin (the USD), wow.
- tim333 2y agoI think the only sensible thing is to treat them as assets with capital gains and losses like any other asset.