4 ms·
Many wars would be cut short if the winning side offered amnesty. I suspect that Germany would have surrendered a year earlier if the Allies had offered some ve
by WalterBright 2y ago
Many wars would be cut short if the winning side offered amnesty. I suspect that Germany would have surrendered a year earlier if the Allies had offered some version of amnesty rather than unconditional surrender.
The Nazis fought to the bitter end because they knew that unconditional surrender meant there would be hell to pay. And there was.
- VagabundoP 2y agoYou run the risk of the old regime continuing in some form and a repeat in a decade of the same war. Germany surrender in The Great War and the world was back at it again 15 years later. This played a big part in the attitude of do it right this time.
- WalterBright 2y agoPerhaps you're right, but it did come with a very large cost in lives on both sides.
- tsimionescu 2y agoNone of the leaders of Germany in WWI were still in power by the time WWII started. The exact opposite lesson was in fact learned by the Allies from WWI: instead of crippling Germany and the other Axis powers like the French did after WWI, they went with the Marshall plan, rebuilding their economies and making sure they have an actual future. The Kaiser wasn't the problem after WWI, it was poverty that allowed the Nazis to rise to power.
- andrepd 2y ago>None of the leaders of Germany in WWI were still in power by the time WWII started. This isn't really true. Hindenburg was instrumental in Hitler's rise to power. Ludendorff was the de facto dictator during WWI and proceeded to create the stab-in-the-back myth and to fight for the Nazis. There is absolutely lots of continuity between the WWI regime and the Nazis.
- WalterBright 2y agoHindenburg was a senile old man at the time. He thought he could control Hitler.
- lupusreal 2y agoAfter Germany surrendered and the war in Europe was over, America began systematically dismantling West Germany's industrial capabilities. No aid was to be given save the absolute minimum needed to prevent starvation, all the work of rebuilding Germany was to be left to the Germans. The Red Cross was forbidden to visit allied camps of German POWs to provide food or aid. It was even forbidden for Americans to send packages of food to Germans. Over the next two or three years these orders were one-by-one rescinded and reversed, mostly for national security reasons when the Soviet threat was acknowledged and Germany's role in countering that Soviet threat was understood. But even then, in the end only a small portion of the Marshall plan went to West Germany. Most of it went to the rest of western Europe.
- actionfromafar 2y ago18 countries got help from the Marshall plan, (West) Germany got 11% of it.
- WalterBright 2y agoBritain and France got the bulk of it, and yet did not experience the economic revival that Germany did.
- egeozcan 2y agoSo many people died... yet, people are still voting for the AfD, and the idea of the Final Solution[0] is still somewhat alive under the Master Plan name[1]. I love Germany, but as a migrant living here, this is a "bit" uncomfortable. I lived here 15 years and paid more than a million in taxes, then suddenly a "Start Remigration Now" poster appears[2]. Not cool. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Solution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Solution [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Potsdam_far-right_meeting#Master_plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Potsdam_far-right_meeting... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Potsdam_far-right_meeting#/media/File:AfD-Wahlplakat_%22Remigration_sofort_starten!%22_in_M%C3%B6dlareuth_20240518_HOF3756_RAW-Export.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Potsdam_far-right_meeting...
- InfiniteLoup 2y ago> and the idea of the Final Solution[0] is still somewhat alive under the Master Plan name[1]. Sorry, but that's utter bullshit. Also, I wonder how you feel about Turkey's plans to remigrate Syrian refugees back to Syria now that Assad has been deposed.
- egeozcan 2y agoNo that's just a fact. It's the same ideology, trying to be sold under "more acceptable" terms. The BS part is people trying to make it sound milder than what it is. It even wants to deport German citizens who they claim to not have integrated well. More details on similarities: https://www.socialeurope.eu/when-never-again-becomes-again-and-again https://www.socialeurope.eu/when-never-again-becomes-again-a... I don't support any forced relocation of groups of people and find even very long prison sentences debatable. I'm also a big proponent of forcing Turkey to recognize the Armenian and other genocides. Nice try to poison the well though. People build their lives somewhere, relocating them usually means many steps back. If you ever migrated into a complete new country with different values and language, you would understand.
- mschuster91 2y ago> Sorry, but that's utter bullshit. Have you missed the last ten years worth of radicalization in the AfD? They started out as what appeared to be a relatively normal fringe party under Lucke, and then over the years the far-right managed to shed ever more layers of the onion. Particularly Höcke, a man who you can legally call a fascist, gives me the chills. And the party youth manages to be even more radical than him, enough to scare the adults into attempting to clean up shop before the youth organization gets banned.
- andrepd 2y ago>And there was Hardly. A handful of very high ranking Nazis were tried and hanged. Many of them escaped via ratlines. Nearly all the mid-level officers and civil authorities escaped any sort of punishment or justice, and continued happily serving in the West German state.
- aguaviva 2y agoA handful of very high ranking Nazis were tried and hanged. This is a misconception. As a result of the "Nuremberg Trials" which concluded in 1946 and focused specifically on high-level defendants, 11 people were hanged. But there were numerous other trials, including what were called the "Nuremberg Military Tribunals" from 1946-1949, the Bergen-Belsen trials, and so on, as a result of which scores of people of decidedly lesser status were executed, easily some 200+. Nearly all the mid-level officers and civil authorities escaped any sort of punishment or justice, and continued happily serving in the West German state. This smells like a major numerical fudge as well.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Hardly. After Berlin fell, soldiers went through all the hospitals and checked every patient for the SS tattoo. Those with them got a bayonet. SS members were hunted and killed throughout Germany after the fall. Some were hung upside down from lampposts and set on fire. Hundreds of thousands of German soldiers died in POW camps after the war. It was open season on German women after the surrender. Germans underwent forced relocations out of Poland. The killing did not stop at the surrender, it slowly faded over the next year. Nearly all WW2 documentaries end with the suicide of Hitler, and maybe the Nuremburg trials. What else happened was savage and not well covered. The Germans had a saying - enjoy the war, because after it will be hell.
- WalterBright 2y agoSome reference material. I don't recommend reading any of them, they're very unpleasant reading. But it's important to document what happened. "After the Reich", NacDonogh "An Eye For An Eye", Sack "Crimes and Mercies", Bacque "Embracing Defeat", Dower "Gruesome Harvest", Keeling "Justice At Nuremburg", Conot "Other Losses", Bacque "The Nuremburg Trial", Tusa "The Long Road Home", Shephard
- actionfromafar 2y agoTeenage german soldiers fought nail and tooth to the death in France in March 1945 for "honour". Suicide-bomber-level brain washing going on.
- pfdietz 2y ago"Ascension Day Commandos" they were called, because of their willingness to die.
- Tor3 2y ago"I suspect that Germany would have surrendered a year earlier if the Allies had offered some version of amnesty rather than unconditional surrender." That assumes that rational thinking (by, in this case, the German side) is involved. There wasn't any, at the very top.
- Gupie 2y agoAn amnesty for what, mass murder, a policy of multiple genocides? Also the Nazis claimed the German army was not losing WW1, but were betrayed by politicians. Perhaps WW2 would not have started if WW1 ended in unconditionally surrender?