4 ms·
From the article: "I would say, generally, it's pretty good on US politics — even local politics." Ctrl-F "bias": 0 results Wikipedia is simply not trustworth
by hmmmmmmmm11 2y ago
From the article: "I would say, generally, it's pretty good on US politics — even local politics."
Ctrl-F "bias": 0 results
Wikipedia is simply not trustworthy on anything remotely political due to the extreme ideological slant of its editors.
- hk__2 2y ago> Wikipedia is simply not trustworthy on anything remotely political due to the extreme ideological slant of its editors. This reminds me of when the BBC reported that they get "complaints from people who feel that [their] reporting of the conflict has been biased against Israel, and complaints from those who feel it has been biased against the Palestinians" [1]. In my experience with the French Wikipedia, it’s the same there, with people from both sides complaining the encyclopedia is biased in favor of the other side. [1]: https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaint/israel-gazacoverage https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaint/israel-gazacoverage
- bawolff 2y agoThe two aren't mutually exclusive. Like they could be biased about certain parts in one direction but the other direction in another. I think we humans have the unfortunate tendency to view things as binary - you are either biased for one side or another. However when we are talking about something like wikipedia with lots of authors or even something like bbc where different articles are written by different people, i think its entirely possible for it to be biased against both sides (and for both sides) in different aspects.
- _carbyau_ 2y agoThat "view things as binary" is a real problem. The world is more detailed, convoluted, fascinating and complex than a binary viewpoint allows.
- WolfeReader 2y agoCan you give an example or two?
- roenxi 2y agoA fun one is to compare its coverage of Trump's Ukraine scandal to Biden's Ukraine scandal. It is a good example of slant being constructed from completely factual reporting. We've got pretty clear kickbacks happening from a Ukraine company to a high ranking US official. It is likely legal in the same way that congressional insider trading is legal - it'd be illegal except for the fact that it affects politicians. Wikipedia doesn't consider there to be anything there worth talking about except for a page on Biden–Ukraine conspiracy theories despite there being, as far as I can tell from reading the related pages, no plausible explanation for what was going on except corruption. Then you go to the Trump page where he prods the Ukrainians to investigate what, prima-facie, looks like pretty serious corruption and we get the short thesis that is the Trump–Ukraine scandal page.
- evenman 2y ago[dead]
- x-complexity 2y agoAlready responded to an earlier comment on this: What Kamala did as A.G. to Daniel Larsen. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42395591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42395591
- Manuel_D 2y agoI find that very popular subjects do, in fact, manage to be relatively unbiased. E.g. Bush or Obama's Wikipedia page is pretty fair. The more eyeballs on a piece, the less likely that egregious bias is to persist. Bias is a lot more prevalent in niche subjects that can go relatively unnoticed. Furthermore, a couple people can effectively lock down a rarely-viewed page and dominate edits. This wouldn't fly on a very popular page, admins would take notice.