2 ms·
> Lobbyist organizations should redirect their power into making the government appropriately tax streaming platforms to fund artists, rather than side with mon
by lolinder 2y ago
> Lobbyist organizations should redirect their power into making the government appropriately tax streaming platforms to fund artists, rather than side with monopolistic corporate players.
Sorry, what? We're talking about streaming platforms here that have contracts with record labels that have contracts with musicians. If those contracts aren't paying musicians enough, why is the solution to impose a new tax on streaming platforms specifically to pay musicians?
From the page they link to:
> The Living Wage for Musicians Act would tax providers’ non-subscription revenues and add a small fee to the price of music streaming subscriptions. DSPs like Spotify offering interactive music streaming services would pass their taxed revenues and royalties to a non-profit collection and distribution fund, that would in turn pay artists in proportion to their monthly streams.
Isn't this what these contracts are supposed to already be doing? If the numbers aren't making sense then the contract needs to renegotiated. If musicians don't have enough power to renegotiate then the government can and should address that. But why would the solution be to use the taxation power to do the job that royalties are already supposed to be doing?
This feels like a classic case of addressing the symptoms (musicians aren't making enough money) while failing to address the actual problem (musicians have no power to negotiate for what they want).
- ozzsama 2y ago>This feels like a classic case of addressing the symptoms <...> while failing to address the actual problem Or even worse, simple virtue signaling.
- x-complexity 2y agoTo solve this issue, copyright needs to be permanently tied to the person who made the work, and can never be transferred. Not allowing copyrights to be transferable grants significant leverage to the artist, whilst also allowing works to enter the public domain via the author's eventual death (or earlier if copyright expires in 20 years as it originally should have).
- AlexandrB 2y agoI just want a streaming service where all the money I pay (minus some fee) goes to artists I listen to. Right now the biggest portion of what I pay for music streaming goes to Taylor Swift and I don't even listen to her albums.