2 ms·
> But if the algorithm responds equally well to highly engaging posts from team A and team B, then ultimately the algorithm is fair, there's a level playing fie
by ben_w 2y ago
> But if the algorithm responds equally well to highly engaging posts from team A and team B, then ultimately the algorithm is fair, there's a level playing field. Would I prefer it if it boosted boring academic papers about nothingburgers that nobody will ever read? I suppose so, but clickbait is the content humanity wants to engage with, regardless of medium. It's up to each team to make sure that their comms are written in a way that cuts through the noise, like with any other form of marketing.
That assumes it's possible to have a "fair" algorithm.
As I don't want to make a point about specific parties, call them Team Purple and Team Mauve.
If Purple voters tend to press "share" and Mauve voters tend to comment with a link back to the original, and the algorithm favours shares, should Mauve adjust their comms strategy, or should the maker of the algorithm adjust the algorithm? And what happens if, even with the best will in the world, both update at the same time and therefore Mauve gets more and more out of sync?
But even then, marketing is a game of "who has the most money" — one dollar one vote, rather than one person one vote.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoSo what do we do if it's impossible to have a perfectly fair system?
- ben_w 2y agoMake sure that processes involving the development of the system — in this case the social media algorithm — are done publicly, with the kind of democratic involvement you would expect for actual legislation.