5 ms·

I liked Reddit back when it was less well known. Now, it just appears that the content appeals to the lowest common denominator. Some of the content is still gr

I liked Reddit back when it was less well known. Now, it just appears that the content appeals to the lowest common denominator. Some of the content is still great (i.e. r/dwarffortress), but a lot of the site has degraded into junk. If anyone has some good subreddits that are still decent, I'd love to know what they are.

adpirz 14y ago
foodforthought truereddit, economics and if you unsubscribe from pics, funny, adviceanimals, aww, and atheism (regardless of whether you are or not, it's just not high quality content), you'll find that things suddenly get a whoooole lot better
topbanana 14y ago
http://m.quickmeme.com/meme/3pv4lu/ http://m.quickmeme.com/meme/3pv4lu/
- RegEx 14y ago
  This might be the first permissible use of quickmeme on HN ;)
zem 14y ago
there are a lot of excellent small subreddit, but their appeal will obviously depend on whether you share that subinterest. some good larger ones are /r/askscience, /r/printsf and /r/coding.
- RegEx 14y ago
  /r/learnprogramming is a great place to learn and contribute
shortlived 14y ago
It's all about the subreddits http://subreddits.org/ http://subreddits.org/
mkr-hn 14y ago
http://www.reddit.com/reddits/ http://www.reddit.com/reddits/ Reddit is what you make it. Nothing more, nothing less.
starpilot 14y ago
/r/securityanalysis is excellent for those interested in analyzing financial securities. It's pretty narrow, but just shows that pockets of deep content do exist on a mostly frivolous site.
burke 14y ago
/r/askscience and /r/depthhub are pretty consistently good.
deveac 14y ago
Well, it's kind of specific, but r/TheoryofReddit is a very interstitial sub that often deals with the questions we're talking about here. I find it to be quality. Here is an interesting comment regarding the submission problem: http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/rbwn4/rank_threads_and_the_frontpage_by_discussion/ http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/rbwn4/ran... You could also check out Hubski. It's a much smaller new community with completely different social feed mechanisms. I like it quite a bit, though the volume of users is small (but growing). The owner coded it from the open source HN code. There have always been differences in the features and mechanics, but mk just completed a redesign that completely removed even stylistic similarities. Time to hit 'reply' and see how badly I mangled this post typing on my phone...
corford 14y ago
I don't use reddit so have a fairly basic understanding of how it works but looking at all these replies about subreddits, it struck me that basically reddit is a web2.0 version of usenet. So I guess that means good content is there, you just need to know where to look :) P.S. for the redditors: I have nothing against reddit, it's just that I'm already drowning in information and never found the time to get in to it.
- awj 14y ago
  That's actually a pretty decent analogy. Obviously the focus on posting links and ranking and such is different, but the user experience of someone totally new is similar. As is the searching for tiny pockets of awesome in a sea of idiocy.
  - corford 14y ago
    Heh heh I love your phrase "searching for tiny pockets of awesome in a sea of idiocy" - that pretty much sums up my entire relationship with the internet :D

adpirz 14y ago

foodforthought truereddit, economics and if you unsubscribe from pics, funny, adviceanimals, aww, and atheism (regardless of whether you are or not, it's just not high quality content), you'll find that things suddenly get a whoooole lot better

topbanana 14y ago

http://m.quickmeme.com/meme/3pv4lu/ http://m.quickmeme.com/meme/3pv4lu/

RegEx 14y ago
This might be the first permissible use of quickmeme on HN ;)

zem 14y ago

there are a lot of excellent small subreddit, but their appeal will obviously depend on whether you share that subinterest. some good larger ones are /r/askscience, /r/printsf and /r/coding.

RegEx 14y ago
/r/learnprogramming is a great place to learn and contribute

shortlived 14y ago

It's all about the subreddits http://subreddits.org/ http://subreddits.org/

mkr-hn 14y ago

http://www.reddit.com/reddits/ http://www.reddit.com/reddits/ Reddit is what you make it. Nothing more, nothing less.

starpilot 14y ago

/r/securityanalysis is excellent for those interested in analyzing financial securities. It's pretty narrow, but just shows that pockets of deep content do exist on a mostly frivolous site.

burke 14y ago

/r/askscience and /r/depthhub are pretty consistently good.

deveac 14y ago

Well, it's kind of specific, but r/TheoryofReddit is a very interstitial sub that often deals with the questions we're talking about here. I find it to be quality. Here is an interesting comment regarding the submission problem: http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/rbwn4/rank_threads_and_the_frontpage_by_discussion/ http://www.reddit.com/r/ideasfortheadmins/comments/rbwn4/ran... You could also check out Hubski. It's a much smaller new community with completely different social feed mechanisms. I like it quite a bit, though the volume of users is small (but growing). The owner coded it from the open source HN code. There have always been differences in the features and mechanics, but mk just completed a redesign that completely removed even stylistic similarities. Time to hit 'reply' and see how badly I mangled this post typing on my phone...

corford 14y ago

I don't use reddit so have a fairly basic understanding of how it works but looking at all these replies about subreddits, it struck me that basically reddit is a web2.0 version of usenet. So I guess that means good content is there, you just need to know where to look :) P.S. for the redditors: I have nothing against reddit, it's just that I'm already drowning in information and never found the time to get in to it.

awj 14y ago
That's actually a pretty decent analogy. Obviously the focus on posting links and ranking and such is different, but the user experience of someone totally new is similar. As is the searching for tiny pockets of awesome in a sea of idiocy.
- corford 14y ago
  Heh heh I love your phrase "searching for tiny pockets of awesome in a sea of idiocy" - that pretty much sums up my entire relationship with the internet :D