3 ms·
> um, that's kind of....the diametric opposite of what an overwhelming majority of Americans just voted for. Not really. ACA, Medicare, Medicaid, and VA's heal
by llamaimperative 2y ago
> um, that's kind of....the diametric opposite of what an overwhelming majority of Americans just voted for.
Not really. ACA, Medicare, Medicaid, and VA's health insurance programs are all extremely popular among voters.
There are lots of issues on the ballot, and approximately no one was voting for Trump's nonexistent "concept of a plan" for healthcare. Feel free to post evidence of "an overwhelming majority" of people voting for Trump's healthcare plan to back up your initial claim, if you'd like.
By the way, the popular vote had less than a 1.5% margin. There was no "overwhelming majority" in any sense.
This was the 49th largest "overwhelming majority" victory ever by popular vote and the 44th largest victory by Electoral College vote. That is to say: an extremely tight race by any measure.
- zzzeek 2y agoOpinion polls arent the same as elections and the people voted in favor of expansion of Medicare Advantage whether that's their preference or not. Considering no Republican president has won the popular vote in 20 years, the relatively small majority popular vote margin is nonetheless quite dramatic in the context of recent history.
- llamaimperative 2y agoHuh? Here's what you said prior to your edit (though your edit isn't actually responsive to my counterargument anyway): > um, that's kind of....the diametric opposite of what an overwhelming majority of Americans just voted for. Please substantiate your claim. There was no overwhelming majority, and even if there were, it does not at all mean that people voted for this particular policy. Again: you're free to provide evidence otherwise.
- zzzeek 2y agoit's not at all the primary point i was making and the army of HN pedants to argue about a particular poorly chosen adjective to pretend somehow that the more important point I made is moot is as usual very tiresome, I edited the post to remove the offending adjective.
- llamaimperative 2y agoYour primary point is there is strong public sentiment toward healthcare privatization. There is no evidence of this claim. If you have any, please provide it. You attempted to provide the election which is not valid evidence for several reasons. There is no evidence of a mandate from the public in the direction you’re suggesting there is.
- archagon 2y agoIt doesn’t matter how popular those programs are. Rich Republicans are furious that their taxes are funding public health care and will stop at nothing to get “their” money back. And now they have full control of the government.
- llamaimperative 2y agoI don't disagree with this. I was taking issue with the characterization that the American people actually want this.